Donmai

esports

Posted under Tags

Veraducks said:

Why is this even a tag? And with no wiki?

Why is post #2792861 tagged with it? What is this tag even for?

Comments explain it, but it's referencing the fact that at a fighting tournament that was being broadcast live a guy had to change his character skin to comply with TV standards, was a big deal actually I remember it. Anyway, the post does directly reference e-sports.

That being said it already has the EVO tag so I find it redundant, most of the posts in the tag currently seem to be overwatch girls wearing team jerseys and the only one actually showing an event is post #3325442. I wouldn't mind having the specific teams tagged instead similar to how we handle traditional sports teams.

I added some more posts to esports that I felt were missing the tag. A couple different things happening in this tag:
- Posts referencing fictional esports organizations or tournaments (post #3325442)
- Posts referencing real life esports players (post #4761336) or events (post #5442281)
- Posts referencing depicting in-game cosmetics made for esports teams (post #3201137)

It might be a good idea to clarify a few things about the tag:
Should esports be used for depictions of real life esports players when they're out of uniform and not playing the game? post #6214276
Should esports be used when a character is wearing an esports team's merchandise? post #2495698
Should esports be used for in-game skins created for esports teams? post #3201139

Personally, I would say "yes" to the first two and "probably yes" to the third one, for simplicity's sake

zetsubousensei said:

I'd vote no for both of these and maintain it'd just be the team tagged based on other sports see post #5224596 which doesn't have ice_hockey tagged, post #6593622 which isn't tagged with basketball, or post #3269743 which isn't tagged with American Football.

This makes sense. My only issue here is that I think "I want to see anime girls wearing (e)sports merchandise" is a reasonable enough ask that there should be some kind of tag for it, like a tag for branded sports team merchandise or something.

Good rename. It's been the name of the Wikipedia article for quite some time now, after originally being a divisive topic.

Regarding when to use the tag, I think it has similar use to virtual youtuber. One of those contextual tags that don't inherently mean anything visual, but will make you expect a number of common elements, themes, and character archetypes.

gfz said:

I like it. So, something like this?

esports apparel favgroup #31306 for posts containing esports-related clothing
esports cosmetic favgroup #31307 for posts containing official or unofficial alternate costumes based on esports teams

So together it would be
esports: Depictions of esports players (post #4761336), references to esports events (post #5574220), depictions of real-life esports events (post #2789778)
esports apparel: Esports team-branded clothing including official uniforms (post #2490840) and fan merchandise (post #5724412)
esports cosmetic: Depictions of official (post #3465434) or unofficial (post #3333307) in-game cosmetics
Does this cover all bases?

1