Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

Vanniaa067

jxh2154 said:

People have been asking for a thread where feedback on uploads could be obtained. So here it is. I have some reservations about how acrimonious this thread is likely to get, and if it turns into nothing more than a flame-fest, I will lock it.

Rules for those requesting feedback:
#1 - You are not guaranteed feedback. It is entirely voluntary to give it.
#2 - Danbooru may simply not be an appropriate place for your favorite art. If so, accept this and move on.
#3 - Try not to be too thin-skinned,and don't take things personally.

Rules for those giving feedback:
#1 - Give constructive feedback only.
#2 - Refrain from name-calling. Asking people to be thick-skinned doesn't mean you're allowed to be insulting.

I don't know if they can delete posts by request, but i want this one deleted
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7369813?q=user%3AVanniaa067

Reply
LarianPiug

Just posted some commissions I had done by an artist but they weren't approved. Two people apparently felt the art was low quality? In terms of resolution it is high definition (and at least I don't feel they are low quality). Don't know what I did wrong if there is anything I can improve.
post #7364307 and the rest of the family of post

Reply
ZixZax

LarianPiug said:

Just posted some commissions I had done by an artist but they weren't approved. Two people apparently felt the art was low quality? In terms of resolution it is high definition (and at least I don't feel they are low quality). Don't know what I did wrong if there is anything I can improve.
post #7364307 and the rest of the family of post

Seems ok to me.

Reply
Howmanytriesdoineed

So first time posting: Post #7366631, Post #7366651, Post #7366723, and Post #7366736.
All of them have 1~3 approvers saying the reason was 'poor quality' despite the posts having absurdres tag on it? I assume that the two are not correlated?
As this was my first time posting, I randomly chose an artist I liked, saw that it had rather few entries, and decided to upload the art to test the waters. Half of it had netorare by chance (not something I specifically went out of my way to choose, I simply like the art-style); should I stick with something vanilla next time?
Is there anything I can do better next time?
Just looking for some clarification.
Please and thank you.

Reply
Giga Skunk

I am interested in why my most recent posts (Not the gaza one, I'm aware of the flame war) have been getting removed.

But I'm more interested as to why I have a pending rating of 5/9 despite me not having anything pending or in appeals rn.

Reply
Giga Skunk

ZixZax said:

Hello. I think my post post #7369238 deserves to be approved because I didn't find any technical issues. Please review and give it a chance.

They probably don't like the weird resolution on it. Ryu seems out of proportion compared to those of the right side of the pic

Reply
John Fantasy XIV

Giga_Skunk said:

But I'm more interested as to why I have a pending rating of 5/9 despite me not having anything pending or in appeals rn.

Posts that were manually deleted consume 5 upload slots. They will be restored when the three-day queue period of that post expires, if I'm not mistaken.

Reply
Laudividni

WinDGo said:

post #7352572 It's technically a lowres crop of the original image, but I approved it and created a tag for the character;
post #7105172 It's slightly better than the child, but what's this source? I'm not familiar with it;
post #7024070 Personally I'm not here for 3D models;
post #6914911 post #6914845 I see no reason to post both. I looked at official art and they're simply comprised of tachi-e images put together in a low effort (post #7085460, asset #19881059). You posted other images with the same sprites, which makes them low quality posts for me, I'd only approve the tachi-e;
post #6787019 post #6786335 They're from a trustful source, but both are cropped duplicates of the scans.

Reply
Giga Skunk

Ubaldo_the_Uploader said:

Posts that were manually deleted consume 5 upload slots. They will be restored when the three-day queue period of that post expires, if I'm not mistaken.

I had this before the most recent post though.

Why was that *manually* deleted though? Couldn’t be because of the comments alone

Reply
1 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 488