Donmai

Any approver who likes Satomi Touka, please reconsider

Posted under General

This topic has been locked.

I'm sorry.

However, Satomi Touka is a relatively less popular character in Magia Record. Even F4samurai, the original developer/author, doesn't seem to give much love to her :-(

I'm aware that I have only one chance to appeal. That's why I think asking for some more visibility to appeal is necessary.

Personally I feel confident that my post #6583196 meets the standard. I think mikagami_jun did a good job this time. Among other approved drawings of Touka-chan, I think his/her work has the quality which is comparable to the others.

Updated by Unbreakable

For future reference, topic #7934 is the place to go. (I'm a contributor, not an approver, so don't 100% take my word for it, but to me her legs appear weirdly short)

Additionally, approvers often don't know the characters or copyrights present in most posted artworks, especially for less-known copyrights. They are mostly supposed to judge based on the actual artwork, not who they like.

Firstly, I have to admit that I'm aware of the feedback thread. However I'm just worried that a long thread probably won't get much visibility.

On the other hand I don't have bunch of pictures to upload/appeal in forseeable future, therefore you guys probably don't have to worry about me complaining "why my uploads don't get approved" over and over again :-)

As for whether her legs appear to be short... I think this is probably just about the style of drawing, see post #5994046 for reference.

I'm also just comparing with other approved drawings of the same character, therefore I think it should be a relative fair comparison.

Okay at the time of writing it got approved. Sorry for disturbance and thanks for help. (ah sorry again for me being too lazy to squeeze out all tags)

1