Posted under Tags
The holding_ice_cream tag is relatively big, with over half a thousand posts. However, most of the ice_cream posts (~17k) do not have this tag. Should it be deprecated/aliased to holding_food? It seems pretty useful, and I would just request an implication, if not for the fact that so few posts have it.
Same with holding_popsicle (except it has ~150 posts, and most of them were tagged by me on impulse, without prior thinking. Before that there was only ~40)
I'd suggest aliasing it into solely holding food. For the same manner we have holding gun tag while there are many types of guns out there (We do not use "holding rifle" or something like that).
But then there are tags such as holding_candy, holding_pizza, etc. (they're directly referenced in holding_food wikipage). Some of them are even less populated than holding_ice_cream. It kinda feels wrong just aliasing (most of) these tags, even though posts are rarely tagged with them properly (look up pizza -holding_pizza, every other post is not tagged)
World_Funeral said:
I'd suggest aliasing it into solely holding food. For the same manner we have holding gun tag while there are many types of guns out there (We do not use "holding rifle" or something like that).
What the fuck do guns have to do with food? If you have nothing to say, say nothing at all, don't try to derail threads like this.
santinetka said:
But then there are tags such as holding_candy, holding_pizza, etc. (they're directly referenced in holding_food wikipage). Some of them are even less populated than holding_ice_cream. It kinda feels wrong just aliasing (most of) these tags, even though posts are rarely tagged with them properly (look up pizza -holding_pizza, every other post is not tagged)
Well, it sounds fine to have more specific holding tags. If so, how about requesting implication for any existing holding_(food_name) with holding_food and the specified food_name?
nonamethanks said:
What the f do guns have to do with food?
Nothing. It was used an example why we commonly use "holding_object"-type of tag while many taggers do not usually use the "holding_specific_object" at all.
BUR #17030 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication holding_ice_cream -> holding_food
create implication holding_ice_cream -> ice_cream
create implication holding_popsicle -> holding_food
create implication holding_popsicle -> popsicle
Sssure then, here
The bulk update request #17030 (forum #242315) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
