Donmai

Missing jacket implications

Posted under Tags

Nameless Contributor

BUR #6697 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

Show

create implication striped_jacket -> jacket
create implication striped_jacket -> striped
create implication two-tone_jacket -> multicolored_jacket
create implication see-through_jacket -> jacket
create implication see-through_jacket -> see-through
create implication checkered_jacket -> jacket
create implication checkered_jacket -> checkered
create implication polka_dot_jacket -> jacket
create implication polka_dot_jacket -> polka_dot
create implication gradient_jacket -> jacket
create implication gradient_jacket -> gradient
create implication vertical-striped_jacket -> jacket
create implication vertical-striped_jacket -> vertical_stripes
create alias silver_jacket -> grey_jacket

First are colors and patterns. Only tags that have instances of undertagging due to missing implications are included.
I'll probably add one or two more BURs below.

Reply
Nacha Login to view Admiral Pectoral
nonamethanks

We do we have beige jacket again? That's not a standard color we should be using.
There's several of these beige tags but unsurprisingly given it's not a standard color, it's being used for yellow, grey and brown with no rhyme nor reason.

I'll remove it from the BUR and change silver_jacket to an alias to grey_jacket.

Reply
Nacha

nonamethanks said:

We do we have beige jacket again? That's not a standard color we should be using.
There's several of these beige tags but unsurprisingly given it's not a standard color, it's being used for yellow, grey and brown with no rhyme nor reason.

I'll remove it from the BUR and change silver_jacket to an alias to grey_jacket.

+1

Reply
Nameless Contributor

nonamethanks said:

We do we have beige jacket again? That's not a standard color we should be using.
There's several of these beige tags but unsurprisingly given it's not a standard color, it's being used for yellow, grey and brown with no rhyme nor reason.

So these should be changed to yellow, grey and brown until beige is empty?

Reply
Shinjidude

nonamethanks said:

We do we have beige jacket again? That's not a standard color we should be using.
There's several of these beige tags but unsurprisingly given it's not a standard color, it's being used for yellow, grey and brown with no rhyme nor reason.

I think it's because there's a gap in our standard colors. Beige or tan shades tend to be in a place that's either too light or not saturated enough to be yellow, not desaturated enough for grey, and not dark enough for brown (there's a huge difference between chocolate (the default brown) and manila). Despite that, it's a very common color. I always found this gap problematic myself.

Reply
Nameless Contributor

BUR #6700 has been approved by @evazion.

create implication denim_jacket -> jacket
create implication frilled_jacket -> jacket
create implication frilled_jacket -> frills
create implication down_jacket -> jacket
create implication fur_jacket -> jacket
create implication flak_jacket -> jacket
create implication fire_jacket -> jacket
create implication studded_jacket -> jacket
create implication safari_jacket -> jacket
create implication impossible_jacket -> jacket
create implication impossible_jacket -> impossible_clothes
create implication turtleneck_jacket -> jacket
create implication turtleneck_jacket -> turtleneck

Different types and materials of jackets.

Updated

Reply
Shinjidude

nonamethanks said:

Well, the issue is that "beige" and all these non-standard colors depend on an user's perception of the color even more so than the usual colors, so we get stuff like post #4510605, post #4544723, post #4509381 and post #3550588 in the same tag. Everyone knows what "red" is, but not everyone might understand what beige exactly is, and they might resort to use it based on canon.

You get that anyway based on what you're seeing. If it was a standard option though and we defined it, things might end up cleaner, even if there was still some variation. I would probably prefer "tan" myself, but it's a very well established color, and you see it in jackets, sweater vests, shorts and pants (khakis) all the time. I don't see why it should be that difficult for people to identify. This is off topic though. Should it be its own thread, or is there a firm veto on considering a new standard color?

Reply
1