Nuke skinny_dipping

BUR #4762 has been rejected.

mass update skinny_dipping -> nude water
mass update skinny_dipping -> -skinny_dipping

Can be searched with a nude bathing search.
Alternatively it could be converted in a pool, or renamed.

I'm not so sure about that search, skinny dipping is not bathing. Most of what is found in nude bathing is people in bathtubs, onsens, ect. which is not skinny dipping, and certainly not what someone would be looking for.

It is however covered by nude swimming, which isn't a very big search, at which point skinny dipping only serves to filter out beings that wouldn't wear clothes to begin with, like fish girls

Skinny dipping is already supposed to be mutually exclusive with bathing, as the wiki states. Also there are examples of wading, soaking feet, etc. that I believe are legitimate uses of the tag and aren't swimming.

Regardless of the outcome of this BUR, what you want to do is update skinny_dipping -> nude water. No need for implications.

Shouldn't it get the pool treatment then, similar to pool #1536?

Username_Hidden said:

Shouldn't it get the pool treatment then, similar to pool #1536?

I'm not sure if pool #1536 is better as a tag or a pool (is casualness too subjective?), but skinny dipping seems like a straightforward enough concept to me. Are they nude and engaging in recreational water related activities(swimming, wading, ect.)? Then they're skinny dipping. I can't think of any reasons it should be a pool. It's a real world activity that I think most people would have at least heard of.

blindVigil said:

I'm not sure if pool #1536 is better as a tag or a pool (is casualness too subjective?), but skinny dipping seems like a straightforward enough concept to me. Are they nude and engaging in recreational water related activities(swimming, wading, ect.)? Then they're skinny dipping. I can't think of any reasons it should be a pool. It's a real world activity that I think most people would have at least heard of.

I don't think it shouldn't be a pool, just as bV said. The concept of skinny dipping is pretty straightforward, while Casual Nudity has no concept but being naked. You could be indoors, you could be outdoors, you could be doing laundry or just sitting around on the ground. The pool is about random activities, while skinny dipping doesn't have such a wide range of things you could be doing.

Guaro said:

Casual Nudity has no concept but being naked. You could be indoors, you could be outdoors, you could be doing laundry or just sitting around on the ground. The pool is about random activities, while skinny dipping doesn't have such a wide range of things you could be doing.

Then why is zenra a tag, if it's the exact same thing (afaik?)?

Username_Hidden said:

Then why is zenra a tag, if it's the exact same thing (afaik?)?

topic #15165.

The bulk update request #4762 (forum #181061) has been rejected by @evazion.