Posted under General
Casval-kun said:
post #2909868
post #2902625
post #2902621
post #2894284
post #2883252
post #2863425
post #2833577Please
First of all. Not breaking Danbooru rules is not really a valid appeal reason unless some moderator erroneously state that it does.
What determines if a post gets approved or not is if a queue moderator likes it enough to approve it.
Also asking us to explain whats wrong with this many posts at once reduces your chances of getting an answer.
post #2909868
Cant really find anything to comment on. The girls are a bit stocky maybe.
post #2894284
Its not a very interesting image. There are a few small anatomical errors like her neck and the gap between her thighs. The shading is a bit odd and their faces are a bit exaggerated.
Taken together these things make for a sub par image.
post #2883252
Kinda sketchy and a bit lowres. Especially the glass ball and the hands holding it. I would say the overall quality is to low for Danbooru.
It is also seriously under tagged but I dont think tagging it better will really help.
post #2863425
The gap between her upper thighs is exaggerated making her left thigh look unconected to her hip. Not an extreme problem but its there.
The way she covers her face and is crying probably put a few mods of to.
post #2833577
This art style is tricky to get through. Chibified characters tend to only fly with people that like the show they are from and these are from four different Gundam series.
I could go on criticising their hands and faces but Il just say I wouldnt even click on this thumbnail if I was a mod.
post #2909868
Cant really find anything to comment on. The girls are a bit stocky maybe.
Bad hands and arm proportions that cannot be explained away with foreshortening.
I was somewhat surprised that post #2923288 wasn't approved. Is it the western castle design?
ion288 said:
I was somewhat surprised that post #2923288 wasn't approved. Is it the western castle design?
I think it's also that it looks a bit like a 3D render and not like a full drawing. In my experience those kind of scenery posts have a much harder time getting approved.
Wondering why post #2931466 got disapproved even though there are many others like it which are fine. (e.g.: post #2108900 or post #1477693)
Keksmonster31 said:
Wondering why post #2931466 got disapproved even though there are many others like it which are fine. (e.g.: post #2108900 or post #1477693)
Let's start:
1. Both examples linked were uploaded by people who did not need to go through the queue.
2. Your post is less well-drawn and colored than the other two, and note the weird proportions on the Jojo-character's head, whether it be anime-style or realistic proportions, it's just wrong.
3. This is something that seems to be repeated every page, but it's worth repeating again: Each image is its own bubble, it doesn't matter what other images that are of similar or worse quality got approved, each image is judged for approval on an individual basis based on the approval team's individual preferences and quality threshold.
Keksmonster31 said:
Thanks for clearing it up and it looks like I need to take another long hard look at the exact rules again (about queues).
Seems like my standards are just different then because it looked pretty okay for me.
Well, I've approved it, but CodeKyuubi is still right about most things.
But it's just scratching the borderline, because the Sakuya still has some meritsand a solo image would've gotten approved just fine (I assume).
The left collarbone seems to be the reason for deletion, correct? I don't know how important this detail is but please look at the whole image. Coloring is soft and comfy, shading is decent and gradient, and drawing is (overall) over average and detailed (ears, hair, skin, a.s.o.) in my opinion. I hope you understand my English and know what I'm trying to say. :)
Marqant said:
The left collarbone seems to be the reason for deletion, correct? I don't know how important this detail is but please look at the whole image. Coloring is soft and comfy, shading is decent and gradient, and drawing is (overall) over average and detailed (ears, hair, skin, a.s.o.) in my opinion. I hope you understand my English and know what I'm trying to say. :)
Imo while the necks are a little long (Or maybe canon for giraffe girl since giraffe, amirite?) I think it looks fine otherwise.
CodeKyuubi said:
Imo while the necks are a little long (Or maybe canon for giraffe girl since giraffe, amirite?) I think it looks fine otherwise.
Its not just that both necks are too long. Her neck is also of centre like its growing out of her left shoulder.
Its almost flag worthy IMHO.
ion288 said:
Its not just that both necks are too long. Her neck is also of centre like its growing out of her left shoulder.
Its almost flag worthy IMHO.
That's more of a shoulder issue, I think. I've seen people at angles and that's how it looks (mostly, it's pushed a little), illusively enough, but the shoulder closer to us needs to be more strongly defined to show that it's between us and the neck. Right now that fails to be the case so it looks like it merges.
a better quality version of another image that was already approved ( post #2639203 ), why was this one deleted?
Same with this one:
post #2886509 (parent of post #2884664 )
Updated
If any of you guys could think why some of these would not be approved? Most of them are by artists whose stuff has been posted/approved before
post #2939494
post #2931435
post #2921150
post #2921090
post #2880962
post #2866730
post #2852904
post #2802180
post #2746001
post #2739560
post #2852912
post #2939494
Parody or not, too western style.
post #2931435
Male only - super niche, most people don't like that.
post #2921150
Weird as fuck, guys with gigantic eyes, it makes me feel sick personally.
post #2921090
Questionable anatomy.
post #2880962
Half/half western/eastern style, well drawn but the style fusion may not be as well received? *shrug*
post #2866730
Eh, what can I say, I think it's just boring.
post #2852904
Western style.
post #2802180
Looks fine to me. Maybe people don't like short haired Peach.
post #2746001
Eh, it's okay. A bunch of things look a little off but it's not too serious.
post #2739560
Looks okay, copyright is niche.
post #2852912
Western style.
Next time don't post so many damn images at once. It's annoying.
Chimera99 said:
Surprised that the first one got deleted.
First one: Weird proportions (small head, big torso, super-long arms)
Second one: Bad anatomy around the butt.
Third one: Bad anatomy, stiff poses.
