Posted under Tags
create implication holding_weapon -> holding
create implication holding_gift -> holding
create implication holding_gift -> gift
create implication holding_hair -> holding
create implication holding_food -> holding
create implication holding_food -> food
The first five implications seem fine enough. Not quite sure about the last one though, since some of the pics actually having the character holding sweets
Updated
nom123 said:
create implication holding_weapon -> holding
create implication holding_gift -> holding
create implication holding_gift -> gift
create implication holding_hair -> holding
create implication holding_food -> holding
create implication holding_food -> foodThe first five implications seem fine enough. Not quite sure about the last one though, since some of the pics actually having the character holding sweets
Ah, I knew there was a thread I wanted to write something.
Well, I don't get your last sentence because I read it like that sweets aren't food?
create implication holding_weapon -> weapon
create implication holding_cup -> holding
create implication holding_cup -> cup
create implication holding_knife -> holding
create implication holding_knife -> knife
Nitrogen09 said:
create implication holding_knife -> knife
I found this post #1541265 under the holding_knife tag. Would straight razors fall under the term "knife" and if not, should the holding_knife tag then not include them or should it include them because of the visual similarity?
NWF_Renim said:
I found this post #1541265 under the holding_knife tag. Would straight razors fall under the term "knife" and if not, should the holding_knife tag then not include them or should it include them because of the visual similarity?
Yes it is, according to the Wikipedia, straight razor is also considered a type of knife.
Well it's more of an issue on whether that's what users would expect to find under the knife tag here. If users would would want to find such depictions under the knife tag, then that's fine. If they do not, then it isn't. What wikipedia says about the matter will be taken into consideration, but in the end its how we wish to define it for our purposes.
As it currently stands, none of the straight_razor images are tagged as knives, which would suggest that taggers visually considered them different from knifes. If that's the case, then the issue is whether holding_knife is then limited specifically to knives or can it also include knife-like. If it's limited to only knives, then the implication makes sense. If it includes knife-like objects, then the implication doesn't make sense.
NWF_Renim said:
Well it's more of an issue on whether that's what users would expect to find under the knife tag here. If users would would want to find such depictions under the knife tag, then that's fine. If they do not, then it isn't. What wikipedia says about the matter will be taken into consideration, but in the end its how we wish to define it for our purposes.
As it currently stands, none of the straight_razor images are tagged as knives, which would suggest that taggers visually considered them different from knifes. If that's the case, then the issue is whether holding_knife is then limited specifically to knives or can it also include knife-like. If it's limited to only knives, then the implication makes sense. If it includes knife-like objects, then the implication doesn't make sense.
Since holding_knife doesn't have a wiki yet, then I'd suggest to explicitly note in the wiki to only include knives, not knife-like object. As for straight razor, it depends on if knife is used as a catch-all tag for all types of knife (which means all *_knife should always imply knife), or just to simply describe the "generic-looking" one.
create implication holding_pen -> holding
create implication holding_pencil -> holding
create implication holding_pencil -> pencil
create implication holding_staff -> holding
create implication holding_staff -> staff
create implication holding_bottle -> holding
create implication holding_bottle -> bottle
create implication holding_tray -> tray
create implication holding_tray -> holding
create implication holding_plate -> plate
create implication holding_plate -> holding
create implication holding_helmet -> helmet
create implication holding_helmet -> holding
create implication holding_camera -> camera
create implication holding_camera -> holding
create implication holding_torpedo -> torpedo
create implication holding_torpedo -> holding
create implication holding_phone -> holding
create implication holding_phone -> phone
More holding x -> holding and x implications. Unless holding torpedo should imply holding weapon instead?
Updated
kuuderes_shadow said:
Unless holding torpedo should imply holding weapon instead?
The wiki for weapon indicates the tag is for handheld weapons, and specifically says "...not with things like cannons or torpedoes". I think that's a good guideline, even if most Kantai Collection torpedos are effectively hand-held.
The bulk update request #809 has been approved.
create implication holding_wand -> holding
create implication holding_wand -> wand
create implication holding_leaf -> holding
create implication holding_leaf -> leaf
create implication holding_pillow -> holding
create implication holding_pillow -> pillow
create implication holding_bouquet -> holding
create implication holding_bouquet -> bouquet
create implication holding_box -> holding
create implication holding_box -> box
create implication holding_bowl -> holding
create implication holding_bowl -> bowl
create implication holding_stuffed_animal -> holding
create implication holding_stuffed_animal -> stuffed_animal
create implication holding_sign -> holding
create implication holding_sign -> sign
create implication holding_pipe -> holding
create implication holding_pipe -> pipe
create implication holding_animal -> holding
create implication holding_microphone -> holding
create implication holding_fork -> holding
create implication holding_fork -> fork
create implication holding_fan -> holding
create implication holding_fan -> fan
create implication holding_paper -> holding
create implication holding_paper -> paper
create implication holding_ball -> holding
create implication holding_ball -> ball
create implication holding_broom -> holding
create implication holding_broom -> broom
create implication holding_drinking_glass -> drinking_glass
create implication holding_drinking_glass -> holding
create implication holding_mask -> holding
create implication holding_mask -> mask
create implication holding_condom -> holding
create implication holding_condom -> condom
create implication holding_cellphone -> holding_phone
create implication holding_cellphone -> cellphone
create implication holding_doll -> holding
create implication holding_doll -> doll
create implication holding_cigarette -> holding
create implication holding_cigarette -> cigarette
more holding x -> holding and x implications.
Updated
Bouquets usually come in wrapping, which is often what is being held, and not the flowers themselves. eg. post #2445471
