Donmai

[Feature Idea] User Promotion Report Update

Posted under General

Right now, we have one single promotion report page on Dabooru:
User Promotions
As you can see, there are only users visible who are uploading images. That means this report is more or less for users who could get the "Unlimited Upload" permission since it features the amount of uploads and the deletion/negative score rate of their uploads.
But in my eyes, "Promotion" is more than just being promoted to Contributor because of uploads. There is also the Builder level status. Those users do most likely great translation work on Dabooru.

The thing is, that there is no promotion report for other contributions as uploading pictures.
As far as I know, there are multiple categories:
1. Note Changes (Translation)
2. Artist Commentary Changes (Adding and/or Translation)
3. Artist Changes (Database clean-up)
4. Wiki Page Changes (Database clean-up)
5. Post Changes (Tag gardening)
6. Pool Chabges (Tag/Post Gardening)

So the idea is to create a user report page for every of those categories. If I missed one: Sorry^^'.
In some kind of ranking for a specific amount of time (year, months, weeks. For example
User 1: 5666 Note Changes in 1 month
User 2: 5123 Note Changes in 1 month
etc.
Since this should help to promote users to Builder level, these lists should only provide informations about users who are lower than Builder status. Or create two seperate lists, like we have for Contributors already. The other list for users who are uploading but are not Contributors is above.

So...any opnion to this^^?

Well, if people think that they will have a big e-peen, than I just feel sorry for that user.
Since the idea is something different and doesm't involve competition, I don't think that this should be a good reason...

+1 to this idea. To address the rational that ghostrigger mentioned, I say "Who cares?" If they are contributing to this site in order to get a higher ranking, then that's an overall net plus to this site. In fact, such a report might even convince more users into doing those helpful activities.

It would also identify those users that are making a lot of recent changes so that more experienced users could check their work to ensure that they are doing things correctly.

This isn't really a motivation booster (although yeah, that is also true. But in the first way it is a helping device.
After I had reported some users (the last promotions starting with OniTea), I thought it would be better to have an easy overview over all activities here on this site. As you can see, these reports are limited to uploading and translating but that is not all. But the other things (especially post changes/tag gardening) are pretty hard to follow^^.

Intro

I figured in the interim (until/if it gets implemented), we could go through the user feedback cycle for this feature idea in order to find something that we like and is usable.

I collected some data for post changes over the last month and have presented them in the table below. Below the table are some change considerations I've thought of.

Data

Post Changes Table
RankBuilder+Post ChangesPlatinum-Post Changes
1Hillside_Moose38621kuuderes_shadow6810
2Provence34213Insanity_Demon1139
3Nitrogen0914586Dinglecockles1090
4RaisingK8809Yawn_Sven940
5zeparoh5799bunkhead715
6EB5029Rignak671
7BrokenEagle984204reiyasona575
8Type-kun2561Erytropus481
9OOZ6622104Unbreakable475
10henmere2079kars41456
11Zettamorose2043Smog_ShadowSeth433
12Sacriven1986fuzzygnome429
13mock1571chodorov400
14NWF_Renim1562Chimera99397
15gary255661299beltman351
16bad_mongo1283RenjiMinomatsu349
17Vid-szhite1151TawdryCognations282
18Benit1491046Flopsy274
19BlindSargent1013NeverGonnaGive227
20Kikimaru969Macco227
21Blue_Trident947transkancolle210
22D'Eye942Timmaine206
23Doragonn925rembang200
24Manatsu-92888JsTuCkEy193
25CharleyDodger881Tayan190
26Jarlath865hungkok2007189
27tapnek860DeadW@nderer184
28Lannihan746RazingK182
29keonas720Sausageroll179
30zaregoto714Chucu178
31dereyoruk685worldendDominator178
32Shallie593Rauvi176
33Randeel574Saiko161
34Rastamepas567Troykv147
35nanami552asianprostitute1500146
36Blue_Stuff540akp47136
37Qpax527matteste132
38CyberWire524arisboch124
39CodeKyuubi513zenjamibu122
40RiderFan504MaxAndEmilytate121
41Elfaleon470Kyuzeth118
42KazuyaRazuKazama466onlyaw118
43Koragg200455windmaker190117
44Fenen430Fortuna115
45Apollyon424Elektronik115
46magenta-crimson394NeoChaos110
47zigzag393Danaii108
48Ars391fjay69106
49Cristianlush385bigp0weR99
50hurrghhurrgh384GoldSaw99
51dean_exia368Gollgagh97
52andalus346Sarangpata95
53Paracite346Tomzai94
54Magus306rollingstart94
55NCAA_Gundam295Cyanide_Exploder94
56Gauron1786288TheQuackSavior91
57Stan_Miller284MisterSolitaire89
58Megamet280TomReidem86
59OniTea275GoogleRules85
60yunashiku257Kronnang_Dunn85
61DeusExCalamus250cirno_goes_in_fridge82
62Tsumanne247AriesWarlock81
63Inferno240cutemi281
64iridescent_slime236hemoglobin79
65Bibs231ilpalazzo-sama78
66mnichu225TJF58875
67OMGkillitwithfire215ion28875
68Evangeline_A.K._McDowell208HawkeyeNFO74
69Stefan86197jise73
70oecchi194zedk870
71Hoppo183ChurchOfGodard70
72fossilnix183Meso'ed69
73SciFi183Swordman_of_a_Distant_Star69
74Tsuki_no_Sakura182Apox68
75Krad_Hunter175AngryJellyfish67
76hatachinatachi174avgnmania65
77recklessfirex173cyanriddle64
78Moonspeaker173archiver66663
79Stun-99163RomanticTP62
80Monki161alt0175661
81Brightlight158sarusa61
82Black_Fox152HentaiBeat59
83Sythini151Silfs59
84D1ce146Promestein59
85HNTI138MisaoFan59
86pikuchan134SionJack58
87Kadoya134Totaku58
88ghostrigger128markyjoe199058
89Tapper118salamandrake57
90Susuka115mattiasc0257
91Youkai_Chili115Deyboard57
92RinkaS113Setsunator57
93Nassan035107fTFzI8YOOJyy7jw956
94ghost_v105vivoleko0156
95aclcher103demosquid56
96Oosaki-m96Nil8r9355
97Guilty34395StormTAG55
98DrLove92jon008355
99MikeTheV91kuugarisingultimate54
100abandoban88tzvetantodorov53

Change Considerations

1. Is the number 100 right for the table size, or should it be more or less?

2. The above numbers include uploads (an upload counts as a post change). Should they pruned?

3. The above numbers include non-edits, i.e. no change was recorded. E.g. this can happen when a tag is added, only for it to be removed by the same person. To see an example, check this page where I was testing the adding and removing of tags. Should these non-edits be pruned?

4. The above includes Admins, and their post change counts include bulk update requests (BUR). There is no easy way to distinguish between a BUR change and a regular change. Should Admins therefore be pruned?

5. The total number of tags added or removed can be calculated separately per user. Is that something that should be shown as well? Should it be a total of the two, or should they be shown separately?

6. The total number of ratings changes can be calculated separately. Is that something that should be shown?

7. The total number of source changes can be calculated separtely. Is that something that should be shown?

8. Basically any tag of interest can be calculated (e.g. tagme, artist_request, copyright_request, etc) including or separate of uploads. Should any other tag be shown?

9. The top N tags added or removed can be calculated per user as well. Is that something that should be shown, and if so, what should N be?

10. Anything else you can think of, such as table look and presentation, separation of builder+ and platinum- table, etc.

Final Thoughts

I am working on computing the other changes (pool,note,commentary,etc.), but wanted to post what I already have.

Anyways, the above is for your consideration. Any comments you have will/may help shape what you (may) eventually get.

Well, such a table is exactly what I was looking for.
Builders+ and Platinum- seperated in two lists: Both for possible positive/negative feedback and the other list is of course also for feedbacksm but should be more used for user promotions since they do good work. Same with the Notes, Artists, Artist Commentary, Wiki Page and Pool Changes, I guess.

1. No real opinion here. Maybe we shouldn't focus on the top changers, but for a fix border.
Like users who haven't done 500 post changes per month should not be included. That would cut off all users below RiderFan or reiyasona on these lists. (Note: Number is an example)

2. Well, no. Otherwise users like zeparoh would have much less tag change amount on these lists and he is one of the best taggers. That wouldn't be fair.

3. If it is possible: Yes. Although I don't think this will do much and can be tracked when I want to create a feedback for you. But when you do this, I might give you a negative because you want a high score. So no :3.

4. That's their job and only admins can do this. So: Nope, since this is a lot of tag gardening that covers multiple posts over multiple years.

5. Well, I guess not. Since one should always look through the list and look what exactly was changed. So this feels a bit unecassary.

6/7 I'd say yes.

For 8/9 I don't really get what you mean^^'.

10: I have norhing to add for now :3.

Provence said:

Builders+ and Platinum- seperated in two lists...

That's what I was thinking, plus if some of those other stats get added in, the table would become unbearably wide.

Provence said:

1. No real opinion here. Maybe we shouldn't focus on the top changers, but for a fix border.

Hadn't considered that, but that's a good idea. For the next version, I'll show a cutoff line of 500.

Provence said:

2. Well, no. Otherwise users like zeparoh would have much less tag change amount on these lists and he is one of the best taggers. That wouldn't be fair.

Okay.

Provence said:

3. If it is possible: Yes. Although I don't think this will do much and can be tracked when I want to create a feedback for you. But when you do this, I might give you a negative because you want a high score. So no :3.

At least for myself, I've only done it on accident or for testing purposes. But I'll go ahead and prune them.

Provence said:

4. That's their job and only admins can do this. So: Nope, since this is a lot of tag gardening that covers multiple posts over multiple years.

Not sure if you're promoting their inclusion or their exclusion. Yes or no, should they be excluded?

Provence said:

5. Well, I guess not. Since one should always look through the list and look what exactly was changed. So this feels a bit unecassary.

6/7 I'd say yes.

Acknowledged.

Provence said:

For 8/9 I don't really get what you mean^^'.

For 8, if you wanted to know who was adding or removing a lot of a certain tag, that could be shown. For example, someone answering a lot of artist requests would have a lot of -artist_request and a lot of <artist_name> tags being added. The same for copyright requests, character requests, copyright requests, source requests, etc. etc.

Number 9 is just a kind of curiosity item. For instance, with the tagging I've been doing lately, small breasts, medium breasts, large breasts, etc. would definitely show up in my top 10, so this would highlight someone that was tag gardening a certain subset of tags.

Provence said:

10: I have norhing to add for now :3.

Thank you for the quick feedback! ^__^

I want Admins to be included^^. They still do tag gardening besides the BURs, so it wouldn't be fair to exclude them. And those BURs are a big thing in tag gardening in general. So Hillside Moose should still be Number 1 :3.

Number 9: If you want to create a positive feedback, you should look what they were adding. So if you point the main points of interest, then this will surely help. I would say that this should be included.

Number 8: Ok, I guess that is more or less the same as Number 9 then:
You have removed 100 artist requests, so this will be highlighted^^.

Oh, I have a thing I want to mention.
It is about this page here:
Site Map
As you can see, there are multiple categories. Most of them are also included in the bar directly under "Danbooru": http://i.imgur.com/P5pWTAu.png
I'm talking about this and this "Site Map" comes up when you click "More >>"

Now, every important category from this Site Map is included there somewhere, EXCEPT the "Artist Commentary" category and the "Report" category. This also includes searches and the "Janitor Trials".

Now the idea is: Include those two categories into that bar since these two categories are buried somewhere in the darkest corners of Danbooru where nobody finds them. That bar is directly clickable on every page you're on Danbooru. That includes the main page, pictures and the forum.
And especially the Janitor Trials and the Artist Commentary are two important categories that goes a bit unnoticed with the recent structure of Danbooru.

Intro

I've compiled the other tables for your consideration. Like before, I leave my change considerations for after the tables.

Data

Pool Changes Table
RankPlatinum-Pool Changes
1Claverhouse97
2Stratfield54
3DGKelly46
4tutcat36
5Tayan32
6Tobi-Sempai32
7Claresa01831
8.musouka27
9Saiko26
10Adept-eX26
11MarqFJA8725
12wheelchair25
13Cliff_Edge23
14hikaritora22
15noth20
16Skribulous19
17Hellbus18
18Swordman_of_a_Distant_Star17
19ZeonTwoSix16
20b4z73rd15
21beltman14
22zarandum114
23fsnfanboy14
24Macco14
25kuuderes_shadow13
26takamachi10
27PCCSantos10
28Kyrozen10
29thatjerk10
30Zetroic10
31Alega10
32infamous10
33PhoenixG10
34Death_Striker9
35Chucu9
36delta8
37silverfly8
38Yuujin-A8
39EcheIII8
40tatteredking8
41GMO8
42TwinLeadersX8
43Darkagma8
44demosquid8
45Nameless_Troll7
46Izkael7
47FenrirDomino7
48arisboch7
49Fallen_Nightingale7
50JsTuCkEy7
51Lilligant7
52TwoGunAngel7
53PhantomDownload7
54DeadW@nderer6
55chodorov6
56Chimera996
5779248cm/s6
58t.satoru6
59Kronnang_Dunn6
60pervstone6
61GratumPraefectus6
62Yamada-ii6
63Runty6
64Catloaf6
65frozen_kyurem5
66Tomzai5
67Apox5
68Doggy88625
69lifestream75
70Super_Deep5
71mattiasc025
72Vezon_The_Insane5
73Calamity20075
74FinderX5
75Alanis_the_Evoker5
76angrybull5
77RomanticTP5
78AyaReiko5
79Eboreg5
80Parnifia_the_Bastard4
81bigp0weR4
82Erytropus4
83MisterSolitaire4
84Hoobajoob4
85aceofspudz4
86BlastingNaba4
87MaxAndEmilytate4
88blazerflare4
89TomReidem4
90yoyoboy4
91Rice_223
92Danaii3
93decondelite3
94Qualtz3
95Deear3
96toshi3
97NeoChaos3
98IsThisName?3
99shujito3
100M_Nagaiisawa3
RankBuilder+Pool Changes
1Jarlath177
2Stan_Miller93
3Sythini86
4andalus72
5BrokenEagle9869
6Zettamorose47
7Provence46
8Tsuki_no_Sakura46
9Lannihan42
10Vid-szhite42
11Hoppo41
12game200937
13fossilnix33
14Brightlight33
15Zekana32
16OMGkillitwithfire32
17RaisingK32
18Sacriven28
19Krugger26
20keonas26
21CharleyDodger26
22KazuyaRazuKazama24
23Blue_Trident24
24Kikimaru23
25Blue_Stuff21
26MikeTheV20
27Manatsu-9220
28Moonspeaker19
29nanami17
30zeparoh15
31dereyoruk15
32Evangeline_A.K._McDowell14
33BlindSargent12
34gary2556611
35Randeel10
36Fenen10
37Kadoya10
38Black_Fox9
39tapnek9
40henmere8
41Benit1498
42Shinhwalee8
43Stefan868
44Tapper8
45EB8
46OOZ6628
47Paracite8
48Bibs7
49Nitrogen097
50Tsumanne7
51T34/387
52yunashiku7
53abandoban7
54firechikara7
55mock6
56Cristianlush6
57oecchi6
58rpgman15
59NNescio5
60iridescent_slime5
61Nero3X4
62Zansnae7934
63ghost_v4
64RiderFan4
65Ashen4
66D1ce4
67Ars4
68S1eth3
69mnichu3
70Wilfriback3
71Krad_Hunter3
72kamikazemonk3
73YumiKanzaki3
74NWF_Renim3
75Type-kun3
76v5718662
77Doragonn2
78Shebadotfr2
79bad_mongo2
80Tetrominon2
81SciFi2
82Monki2
83NinjaPope2
84pikuchan2
85Demundo2
86BakaHoushi2
87Qpax2
88Elfaleon2
89Hillside_Moose2
90LionPride881
91bigrich1
92cnmanx1
93Shallie1
94UserID 4396901
95Apollyon1
96zaregoto1
97Stun-991
98Bansho1
99Gauron17861
100Ichi_Zeroth1
Note Changes Table
RankPlatinum-Note Changes
1Izkael709
2Nil8r93449
3akiored357
4Rice_22316
5Tobi-Sempai288
6Vezral205
7KyteM194
8infamous181
9HachYguy155
10highmega140
11OOhara128
12TwinLeadersX124
13fTFzI8YOOJyy7jw9116
14Tayan105
15ExDragonMaster104
16VierMill102
17Shounen_Fake101
18crownofleonidas93
19YamCakes93
20RomanticTP91
21cirno9baka91
22MagnaArashi90
23NightWave89
24Catloaf89
25HentaiBeat82
26inflexion75
27Wolffy00068
28WhiteCrow68
29M_Nagaiisawa65
30BDR62
31Captain_Zero59
32Wooberjig58
33cyrilkhan58
34SociallySuperfluous54
35ittybitty53
36sarusa53
37zsphoenix50
38ScreaminJamaicanYeti46
39tehSandwich46
40The_Shadow44
41haita44
42Broducer43
43toshi42
44Estavali42
45MrSusher40
46Lost+39
47BlizzardMan.EXE37
48aceofspudz37
49gwanleen36
50Zhuangzi34
51PapayaWarfare34
52shade_3034
53whitebase32
54Tinx20a32
55ADT55531
56cosmic+T5v231
57TroublesomeTroubadour30
58UnlikeSuika30
59Uhjinhyuk5530
60achlorine30
61Synchronous30
62worldendDominator29
63Victor3y28
64Grisoni27
65a0r10n27
66mgdtgd27
67DozingClip26
6813ad_1iar26
69.k1.38e+2325
70Newcastle25
71BlastingNaba24
72DGKelly21
73tklh2721
74infinite_cityscape21
75kuuderes_shadow20
76emithith20
77lesher19
78Allaire19
79uchuunamako19
80Danaii19
81hemlock19
82Takeshi2219
83sunember12318
84GODAMNITatsuta18
85Masaru.18
86wahahahaha17
87Chucu17
88jinsoba17
89Acorunix17
90ShanghaiAliceHolic216
91paperwolf16
92TFC16
93aLynte16
94HentaiHarvester16
95Kyuzeth15
96puyo215
97Engrishname15
98fjay6915
99arisboch15
100Fyhlen15
RankBuilder+Note Changes
1Paracite2848
2Stan_Miller1479
3Moonspeaker1268
4hatachinatachi1240
5OMGkillitwithfire1087
6yunashiku1076
7Nassan035718
8Vid-szhite661
9Evangeline_A.K._McDowell554
10BrokenEagle98490
11Nagumo416
12Elf_song378
13RaisingK357
14Bansho329
15Tetrominon325
16CGrascal321
17enneuni311
18JuanValdezJr257
19kittey243
20xYASHAx214
21persocom01202
22Demundo197
23Jarlath178
24CharleyDodger172
25usr234162
26NNescio162
27Ichi_Zeroth144
28recklessfirex140
29NinjaPope131
30Sythini122
31pikuchan117
32firechikara106
33Brightlight96
34_dk84
35natural-log83
36Hoppo78
37Toks77
38Zettamorose73
39Manatsu-9263
40Doragonn60
41palesse57
42Nitrogen0955
43EB53
44henmere48
45Tsumanne48
46tapnek46
47BarefeetChaser40
48Magus35
49Inferno34
50mock33
51zeparoh28
52OOZ66227
53Stefan8624
54Fenen24
55Krad_Hunter23
56Blue_Stuff23
57UserID 43969018
58Kadoya14
59andalus12
60Tapper12
61zaregoto12
62Shinjidude12
63game200911
64Ars11
65Shallie11
66mutopis11
67Blue_Trident9
68fossilnix8
69Seika8
70bakudan008
71BlindSargent8
72Laethiel8
73Megamet8
74Type-kun7
75HigherFive7
76OniTea7
77Shima7
78Sacriven7
79Youkai_Chili7
80abandoban6
81T34/386
82Tsuchino6
83Provence5
84Benit1495
85Zekana5
86Saladofstones4
87varrach4
88memento_mori4
89DeusExCalamus4
90Kikimaru3
91magenta-crimson3
92Lannihan3
93Oosaki-m3
9410half3
95jjj142
96NWF_Renim2
97Monki2
98upupu2
99Krugger2
100WAHa_06x362
Artist Changes Table
RankPlatinum-Artist Changes
1chodorov94
2kars4125
3FaithSummers17
4SionJack12
5Rignak8
6mediocrates7
7Timmaine7
8DarknessNEKO6
9Chucu6
10cyanriddle4
11poppoko4
12kuuderes_shadow4
13Saduharta4
14dandan3
15Copycat2183
16jmm3
17Danaii3
18JohnFreeman3
19HentaiBeat3
20g3gen2
21ZetaPulse2
22Reveiller2
23Noah-Dragoon2
24MaullarMaullar2
25Adept-eX2
26Sausageroll2
27avgnmania2
28emithith2
29KyteM2
30Amoriderefarfalla2
31PrometheusDan2
32PaizuriKin2
33MaxAndEmilytate2
34rollingdice2
35m_rtv2
36Bleach2
37lahdeedah2
38Metalsnakezero1
39krewa1
40Promestein1
41D3FAULT1
42monkey1891
43djseifer1
44transientfaith1
45Eryops1
46liquidfreedom881
47KazukiNanako1
48Felice1
49RomanticTP1
50ermode1
5190sAnimeFan1
52ukeyyy1
53colBoh1
54pc881
55AyaReiko1
56pkmntrainer71
57kthxbai1
58Omegamagnum1
59Miikaaeeel1
60Phuong1
61Macco1
62Cyanide_Exploder1
63bitofhope1
64Pyrolight1
65Grandotron1
66GabrielWB1
67madscientist1
68lebachqui1261
69dipdongs1
70Nineball1
71SN331
72sun1241
73MisterSolitaire1
74gwanleen1
75ShippoLover1
76NagaShoes1
77Ai-to-Yukai1
78mukakego1
79amoralist1
80Dan-H-B1
81Wolffang6851
82Combopan1
83lozeki1
84darkstrong1
85user_4914111
RankBuilder+Artist Changes
1RaisingK908
2henmere466
3tapnek127
4Kikimaru90
5Zettamorose86
6Cristianlush85
7Nitrogen0972
8Shallie58
9keonas56
10Qpax36
11Elfaleon36
12D1ce35
13Blue_Stuff35
14Youkai_Chili31
15andalus30
16Stefan8630
17BlindSargent29
18Provence29
19Sacriven27
20nanami23
21KazuyaRazuKazama22
22CharleyDodger21
23Tsuki_no_Sakura21
24BrokenEagle9819
25DeusExCalamus19
26Randeel17
27Magus16
28RinkaS15
29pikuchan14
30Gauron178613
31zeparoh13
32OniTea12
33dean_exia12
34mock12
35zaregoto12
36Lannihan11
37aclcher11
38Megamet10
39Inferno9
40NinjaPope9
41Fenen9
42fossilnix8
43abandoban7
44mnichu7
45lxs7
46Doragonn6
47Mordon6
48gary255666
49EB6
50Tsumanne6
51Evangeline_A.K._McDowell5
52oecchi5
53Krugger5
54Vid-szhite5
55albert5
56Benit1494
57Hillside_Moose4
58ghostrigger4
59reese3
60Monki3
61Dbx3
62Jarlath3
63UserID 4396903
64hurrghhurrgh3
65HNTI3
66Tapper3
67upupu3
68LionPride883
69Sal.N2
70animeboy122
71hatachinatachi2
72bad_mongo2
730xC0FFEE2
74Zansnae7932
75Hoppo2
76Brightlight2
77Grahf2
78Nero3X2
79Anonymous90001
80firechikara1
81kyouray1
82kn84859091
83Blue_Trident1
84CyberWire1
85buehbueh1
86BakaHoushi1
87[KN]1
88TheodoricBlood1
89CodeKyuubi1
90OMGkillitwithfire1
91YumiKanzaki1
92Shinjidude1
93Apollyon1
94jjj141
95Nonsense1011
96theadonicus1
Artist Commentary Changes Table
RankPlatinum-Commentary Changes
1windmaker19059
2Timmaine53
3BlastingNaba34
4chodorov33
5mediocrates30
6SilencioLove29
7akp4729
8kars4126
9dandan26
10EcheIII25
11Meso'ed25
12sarusa25
13Sausageroll24
14Kapten-N21
15NWSiaCB18
16Copycat21816
17RomanticTP15
18Rufena13
19HalfTheBattle13
20djseifer13
21kuuderes_shadow13
22worldendDominator11
23Ai-to-Yukai10
24GabrielWB10
25akiored10
26Catloaf10
27Bleach10
28nayami10
29HentaiHarvester9
30haita9
31DanmakuShooter9
32Elektronik8
33transientfaith8
34Tomzai8
35Adept-eX8
36t.satoru8
37Ichnob8
38rollingstart7
39FaithSummers7
40MarqFJA877
41TwinLeadersX7
42Nineball7
43Danaii7
44Chucu7
45Tayan6
46Yuichi_Nietzche6
47Erebea6
48pleaseseethereasonfield6
49LilToHo5
50akumaten5
51hanesco5
52HachYguy5
53Chimera995
54KaiserKnuckle4
55Zelinkokitsune4
56Wahid4
57Urawa4
58Chagen464
59GiveUpTheGhost4
60KZN024
61tehSandwich4
62tineutk4
63Mr.Stuff4
64Eraser_stp4
65jinsoba3
66cyrilkhan3
67HaxtonFale3
68zsphoenix3
69KyteM3
70Hellbus3
71sunember1233
72KirbyLord3
73CinderBH3
74PCCSantos3
75Grisoni3
76poppoko3
77CoffeeMilkDrinker3
78Ichigo693
79thatjerk3
80Kilias3
81Insanity_Demon3
82Tobi-Sempai3
83CaesarsSalad3
84ExDragonMaster3
85camellia07263
86daniel953122
87Shintear2
88MisterSolitaire2
89Stellarium2
90tf_charge2
91Paz_Legalces2
92Moriyama2
93Uhjinhyuk552
94zgryphon2
95TJF5882
96TKShadow2
97MagnaArashi2
98mukakego2
99emithith2
100JsTuCkEy2
RankBuilder+Commentary Changes
1Sacriven1093
2dereyoruk322
3Jarlath305
4andalus265
5Moonspeaker135
6RaisingK129
7Kikimaru126
8Vid-szhite121
9Sythini93
10Brightlight90
11BlindSargent84
12Krugger80
13Stun-9976
14Hoppo69
15albert57
16BrokenEagle9851
17henmere50
18Stan_Miller48
19Blue_Stuff44
20Blue_Trident42
21Krad_Hunter41
22Paracite41
23Elf_song40
24EB40
25KazuyaRazuKazama39
26fossilnix39
27Tsumanne33
28mock26
29Lannihan25
30Nero3X24
31Randeel22
32Nitrogen0922
33Qpax21
34Youkai_Chili19
35Bansho17
36Kadoya17
37OMGkillitwithfire16
38Zettamorose15
39firechikara15
40Provence12
41UserID 43969012
42yunashiku11
43v57186611
44zeparoh11
45NNescio10
46Fenen10
47OniTea10
48YumiKanzaki10
49tapnek10
50Stefan8610
51Toks9
52bad_mongo9
53CharleyDodger9
54Ola8
55recklessfirex8
56gary255668
57bigrich8
58palesse8
59CGrascal7
60Doragonn7
61ninryu7
62Gauron17866
63Zekana6
64NCAA_Gundam6
65keonas5
66JuanValdezJr5
67Evangeline_A.K._McDowell5
68Ars5
69Elfaleon5
70persocom014
71Demundo4
72zaregoto4
73pikuchan4
74D1ce4
75Nassan0353
76Tapper3
77CodeKyuubi3
78jjj143
79DeusExCalamus3
80_dk3
81Dbx3
82Type-kun3
83Tsuki_no_Sakura2
84Seika2
85A_Sentient_JDAM2
86T!ramisu2
87oecchi2
88magenta-crimson2
89mutopis2
90reese2
91rpgman12
92hatachinatachi2
93Shinjidude2
94T34/382
95bakudan002
96Nagumo2
97hurrghhurrgh2
98Pianist1
99lkjh0981
100NWF_Renim1
Wiki Page Changes Table
RankPlatinum-Wiki Changes
1Sausageroll32
2Chucu28
3chodorov22
4zedk819
5NeoChaos17
6fuzzygnome16
7poppoko14
8DeadW@nderer14
9KaiserKnuckle12
10Adept-eX11
11kuuderes_shadow11
12Timmaine10
13tehSandwich9
14Nitramy9
15Saduharta8
16PCCSantos8
17TwoGunAngel8
18WatcherCCG7
19Kronnang_Dunn7
20MegaFlare6
21Houou6
22kuugarisingultimate6
23Tomzai6
24Promestein5
25FaithSummers5
26Bicorn5
27kiyah1234
28Famenag4
29Tayan4
30EAF-20003
31TheGreens3
32Cyanide_Exploder3
33ignoremoi3
34zgryphon3
35lahdeedah2
36Ctis2
37mario12772
38kars412
39ZeonTwoSix2
40dimsun2
41Amoriderefarfalla2
42AyaReiko2
43Noah-Dragoon2
44Agamemnon-HR2
45JackyHF2
46Adolf952
47jacplac972
48avgnmania2
49Skyragi2
50coolyo2942
51IDFK_Omega2
52Nil8r932
53LittleFuzzy2
54Copycat2182
55Dinglecockles2
56onlyaw2
57Troykv2
58Insanity_Demon2
59Kyuzeth2
60zenjamibu2
61Ryuken1
62Commander_Rocks1
63lordcantaloupe1
64carguy17011
65qq9518573841
66sirpoo1
67mattiasc021
68Eryops1
69DarknessNEKO1
70Urzur1
71Synchronous1
72giggapuff1
73Bleach1
74AirmanIsEasy1
75arisboch1
76DAS581
77krewa1
78needmoarbaccano!1
79CoffeeMilkDrinker1
80TKStyles24681
81nanokarumia1
82vivoleko011
83emithith1
84Eraser_stp1
85Kishin_Futomimi1
86m_rtv1
87Tobi-Sempai1
88PaizuriKin1
89colBoh1
90Yuujin-A1
91mamott991
92Darrman1
93Lacertilia1
94Phuong1
95Evertide1
9679248cm/s1
97HentaiBeat1
98Neon_the_Chao1
99MaullarMaullar1
100Sweetiebot1
RankBuilder+Wiki Changes
1henmere424
2Zettamorose79
3Benit14979
4keonas51
5zeparoh51
6bad_mongo47
7EB45
8Fenen32
9CharleyDodger32
10BlindSargent29
11Kikimaru26
12Sacriven22
13tapnek19
14BrokenEagle9816
15Nitrogen0916
16mock14
17Blue_Trident14
18Elfaleon14
19Tapper13
20Magus12
21Mordon12
22oecchi11
23Lannihan11
24Gauron17869
25D'Eye8
26Cristianlush7
27OniTea7
28Brightlight7
29Provence6
30Randeel6
31Hillside_Moose6
32Vid-szhite6
33ghostrigger5
34Krad_Hunter5
35Stefan865
36iridescent_slime5
37T34/385
38D1ce5
39fossilnix4
40Youkai_Chili4
41Blue_Stuff4
42Doragonn4
43pikuchan4
44Inferno4
45Shallie4
46Laethiel3
47reese3
48Manatsu-923
49Hoppo3
50andalus3
51NWF_Renim3
52Bansho3
53nanami3
54stoicapple2
55DeusExCalamus2
56kyouray2
57dean_exia2
58Monki2
59Xeano942
60Nero3X2
61BakaHoushi2
62kn84859091
63Qpax1
64lkjh0981
65Saladofstones1
66hatachinatachi1
67OMGkillitwithfire1
68Jigsy1
69Apollyon1
70Mavado1
71gary255661
72Jarlath1
73lxs1
74RaisingK1
75v5718661
76TicClick1
77abandoban1
78aclcher1
79hurrghhurrgh1
80Type-kun1

Change Considerations

1. Wasn't sure what the cutoff should be for each category, so I just included the top 100 from each category if possible. So what should the cutoff be for each category?

2. For all of the above, anything other than the fact that a new version was created is harder to find client-side using only JSON requests. This is because each JSON reply only contains the data as is, not the changes that were made (unlike the post version replies). Not sure if this would cause any of the same issues server-side.

3. Disregarding #2 above, if it were possible, what else would you want to know about a category given the following data for each category, either changes (adds or removals) or non-changes?

  • a: Wiki pages: "title", "other_names", and "body"
  • b: Artist pages: "name", "other_names", and "url_string" (list of urls)
  • c: Artist commentary pages: "original_title", "original_description", "translated_title", "translated_description"
  • d: Note pages: "x" and "y" position, "width" and "height", and "body"
  • e: Pool pages: "name" and "post_ids" (list of posts) Note: Pool versions do not track changes to the "description".

Final Thoughts

Like before, any comments you have will/may help shape what you (may) eventually get.

Edit:

Forgot to mention, but if you don't see your name in the above tables and your username is comprised of special characters (i.e.unicode characters), try searching by your user ID instead. The default Python install doesn't really like encoding those characters...

Updated

As for the cutoffs, I can't say much, but they shouldn't be the same.
And as I said I wouldn't include a N amount of users, but a border X.

"You need X note changes to be listed in the rankings"
And as for every category, it's hard. But I guess for the post changes 500 changes/month would be a good amount since tag gardening is boring and sometimes it takes very long. So this should be a good amount.

For the remeining categories, I've no clear opinion, so maybe calling the top users on each list here, so that they can give a good benchmark if they approve of this. And as I said: The mark should be different for every category.
So...
Note Changes: @Paracite @Stan_Miller @Moonspeaker
Pool Changes: @Jarlath @Claverhouse
Artist Changes: @RaisingK @tapnek
Artist Commentary: @Sacriven @dereyoruk
Wiki Page Changes: @henmere

Note: I think everyone can give their opinion, if they approve of this idea, but I guess these guys can give a good evalution how much work this requires.

For Artist Commentary category, I propose to set the benchmark at 200 - 300 changes. This is because it's simple to "do" artist commentary, but also very tiring. You can say the "difficulty" is average, for it stays at the grey zone between "easy" and "hard". Also, artist commentary is pretty tricky to edit, especially when the posts are come from Twitter, Tumblr, and Seiga. For Twitter case, due to the existence of hyperlink on its Tweets, it needs extra attention for it (i.e. http://danbooru.donmai.us on a Tweet will change into http://t.co/xxxxx).

Well, pretty much all of that is the reason.

I just do a lot of artist changes because I find myself uploading art from a lot of new artists and finding new information on artists frequently. Having good Google-fu helps. As for a benchmark, I'm the wrong guy to ask for that.

Also, is it feasible to have a Ruby interpretation of what BrokenEagle did to get those stats and incorporate it into the Danbooru website since it runs on Ruby?

1 2 3