Posted under Tags
create alias onepunch_man -> one_punch_man
create alias onepunch-man -> one_punch_man
create alias one-punch_man -> one_punch_man
This, to me, seems the most visually neutral format for the tags, in light of varying compounds and hyphenations. This double-spaced format is, at least, seen during the anime's commercial bumps, to justifying using it at all.
EDIT: Preference to NWF_Renim's request below.
Updated
In topic #12171 agreement seemed to be in the direction of using one-punch_man.
create alias onepunch_man -> one-punch_man
create alias onepunch-man -> one-punch_man
create alias one_punch_man -> one-punch_man
create alias saitama_(onepunch_man) -> saitama_(one-punch_man)
create alias fubuki_(onepunch_man) -> fubuki_(one-punch_man)
create alias king_(onepunch_man) -> king_(one-punch_man)
create alias bang_(onepunch_man) -> bang_(one-punch_man)
create alias doutei_(onepunch_man) -> doutei_(one-punch_man)
create alias garou_(onepunch_man) -> garou_(one-punch_man)
create alias yamazaru_(onepunch_man) -> yamazaru_(one-punch_man)
create alias matsuge_(onepunch_man) -> matsuge_(one-punch_man)
create alias snake_(onepunch_man) -> snake_(one-punch_man)
create alias sea_king_(onepunch_man) -> sea_king_(one-punch_man)
create alias bearded_staff_(onepunch_man) -> bearded_staff_(one-punch_man)
create alias d-pad_(onepunch_man) -> d-pad_(one-punch_man)
create alias stinger_(onepunch_man) -> stinger_(one-punch_man)
create alias forte_(onepunch_man) -> forte_(one-punch_man)
create alias red_nose_(onepunch_man) -> red_nose_(one-punch_man)
create alias glasses_(onepunch_man) -> glasses_(one-punch_man)
create alias hyottoko_(onepunch_man) -> hyottoko_(one-punch_man)
create alias butcher_(onepunch_man) -> butcher_(one-punch_man)
create alias beast_king_(onepunch_man) -> beast_king_(one-punch_man)
create alias blue_fire_(onepunch_man) -> blue_fire_(one-punch_man)
create alias zenko_(onepunch_man) -> zenko_(one-punch_man)
Qualified characters (including deleted posts).
The following have zero hits:
alias drive_knight_(onepunch_man) -> drive_knight_(one-punch_man)
alias blast_(onepunch_man) -> blast_(one-punch_man)
alias pig_god_(onepunch_man) -> pig_god_(one-punch_man)
alias tatsumaki_(onepunch_man) -> tatsumaki_(one-punch_man)
alias mosquito_girl_(onepunch_man) -> mosquito_girl_(one-punch_man)
alias sonic_(onepunch_man) -> sonic_(one-punch_man)
create alias terrible_tornado -> tatsumaki
create alias silverfang -> bang_(one-punch_man)
create alias child_emperor -> doutei_(one-punch_man)
create alias drive_knight -> kudou_kishi
create alias pig_god -> butagami
create alias superalloy_blackluster -> chougoukin_kurobikari
create alias watchdog_man -> bankenman
create alias flashy_flash -> senkou_no_flash
create alias tank-top_master -> tanktop_master
create alias metal_bat -> kinzoku_bat
create alias puri-puri_prisoner -> puri_puri_prisoner
create alias handsome_kamen_amai_mask -> ikemen_kamen_amaimask
create alias hellish_blizzard -> fubuki_(one-punch_man)
create alias license-less_rider -> mumen_rider
create alias speed-o'-sound_sonic -> onsoku_no_sonic
Taken from the second anime trailer
From what I understand, the manga and English adaptations of both have alternate names for some, including matters of spacing/hyphenation/what-have-you. So, in my ignorance, I've only put these without qualifiers to their standing tags (assuming the *_(one-punch_man) alias are approved).
BUR #5854 has been rejected.
create alias tornado_of_terror -> tatsumaki_(one-punch_man)
create alias tatsumaki -> tatsumaki_(one-punch_man)
create alias atomic_samurai -> kamikaze_(one-punch_man)
create alias metal_knight -> bofoi_hakase_(one-punch_man)
rename zombieman -> zombieman_(one-punch_man)
rename kudou_kishi -> kudou_kishi_(one-punch_man)
rename butagami -> butagami_(one-punch_man)
create alias superalloy_darkshine -> chougoukin_kurobikari_(one-punch_man)
rename chougoukin_kurobikari -> chougoukin_kurobikari_(one-punch_man)
rename bankenman -> bankenman_(one-punch_man)
rename senkou_no_flash -> senkou_no_flash_(one-punch_man)
create alias demon_cyborg -> genos_(one-punch_man)
create alias genos -> genos_(one-punch_man)
rename kinzoku_bat -> kinzoku_bat_(one-punch_man)
rename tanktop_master -> tanktop_master_(one-punch_man)
rename puri_puri_prisoner -> puri_puri_prisoner_(one-punch_man)
S-class heroes.
Viz & fan translation names.
kia'ra said:
BUR #5854 has been rejected.
Show
create alias tornado_of_terror -> tatsumaki_(one-punch_man)
create alias tatsumaki -> tatsumaki_(one-punch_man)
create alias atomic_samurai -> kamikaze_(one-punch_man)
create alias metal_knight -> bofoi_hakase_(one-punch_man)
rename zombieman -> zombieman_(one-punch_man)
rename kudou_kishi -> kudou_kishi_(one-punch_man)
rename butagami -> butagami_(one-punch_man)
create alias superalloy_darkshine -> chougoukin_kurobikari_(one-punch_man)
rename chougoukin_kurobikari -> chougoukin_kurobikari_(one-punch_man)
rename bankenman -> bankenman_(one-punch_man)
rename senkou_no_flash -> senkou_no_flash_(one-punch_man)
create alias demon_cyborg -> genos_(one-punch_man)
create alias genos -> genos_(one-punch_man)
rename kinzoku_bat -> kinzoku_bat_(one-punch_man)
rename tanktop_master -> tanktop_master_(one-punch_man)
rename puri_puri_prisoner -> puri_puri_prisoner_(one-punch_man)S-class heroes.
Viz & fan translation names.
Why do we need a qualifier for Puri Puri Prisoner again? And Chougoukin Kurobikari?
And what's the point of changing more readily distinguishable names like Atomic Samurai (アトミック侍, his 'superhero' identity name) that doesn't even need a qualifier... to something less distinguishable like "Kamikaze" and then adding a qualifier on top? Most of the suggested BURs just seem ill-advised.
Also... Demon_cyborg? How many people search for Genos under that name anyway? In fact ironically Demon_cyborg is the one that would more likely require a qualifier than genos because it's generic enough to potentially conflict with other demon_cyborgs in other franchises. And having the alias also clogs up autocomplete for demon_, which is already more than saturated. Here his superhero alias is far worse than his usual name.
I suppose oni_cyborg might be less ambiguous, but that's even far less likely to be searched.
As for Metal Knight... his superhero alias is potentially ambiguous, so changing the primary to his name would be appropriate. Though think people are more likely to search him under Dr. Bofoi or just bofoi instead of bofoi hakase. Also most of the other _hakase also have their titles translated into Dr., like Dr. Light.
Though I'd agree that Tatsumaki prolly needs the qualifier. But overall, -1, strongly against.
Updated
@NNescio
I use this OPM wikia https://onepunchman.fandom.com/wiki/Heroes
kia'ra said:
@NNescio
I use this OPM wikia https://onepunchman.fandom.com/wiki/Heroes
You mean the wikia that disagrees with some of your proposed changes? The same wikia that also prefers, in order, Bofoi, Dr. Bofoi, and Metal Knight over "Bofoi Hakase"? (and also Superalloy Darkshine over Chougoukin Kurobikari, incidentally, though that one's a lost cause because of Viz translation conflicts)
Because all those names are more likely to be used by English speakers?
Anyhow, still doesn't change that qualifiers are completely unnecessary for Puri Puri Prisoner. And that practically nobody would type "demon_" when they can just type "genos" instead, and that the character Genos is far better known by the fanbase under his "Genos" name because that's what Saitama calls him all the time. And that demon_ also clogs up the autocomplete list for no good reason, for an alias that practically nobody would type anyhow. It's like suggesting caped_crusader/dark_knight -> batman just because the character also has that name as an in-universe alias.
(Also, ironically, despite the preference for using transliterated names for most of the other tags instead of more intuitive-to-an-English-speaker translated ones, "Demon" itself is also a translation. The original word in Japanese is "Oni".)
Same goes for Kamikaze too, to a lesser extent.
Updated
This is why I hate it when people make requests for multiple things at the same time ("let's qualify these random characters" and "let's totally rename these other characters" and "let's add utility aliases for these other characters"). It's really hard to figure out what to do when we're arguing over multiple issues at the same time.
The bulk update request #5854 (forum #188444) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.
