Feedback

Can a uploader get negative feedback for making several bad upload, even though it's his first mistake ever? By that I mean me, Stan, cause I see peeps been discussing about giving me negative feedback for the bad upload of the artist dupp_akiru.
I'm not defending myself or anything, just asking. If folk really want to give me a minus for my first mistake, then I welcome it. Be a lesson for my future uploads.

A neutral record as a warning is enough. A negative record for your first time is kind a harsh.

Unless it's insanely bad or something, neutral is sufficient.

I really wouldn't even expect any of the users here to use the feedback function. The only lesson I can see from this incident is that dupp_akiru needs more practice.

I'd say you're doing fine, if you pick an artist and someone nukes your uploads then it's on them to justify their flagging. With your track record I don't think you deserve to be rated down for it. Some uploaders never say a thing and continue to post poor material, but you're taking responsibility and have standards. Thats the mark of a real contributor. Just be choosier in the future and that should be good.

Man, I think after this incident ,I'll never go posting single images from unfamiliar artists with very few post uploaded over the course of many years. I'm not a very good judge for quality.
I'm just gonna stick to upload and translate comics from now on, safer that way.

The single comment suggesting to give you a negative feedback was done by a Member-level user, which can't even give you one - I think they was just adding fuel to fire, some people find that fun. Aside from that, you'll have no side-effects even if all those flagged images will get deleted, as it won't affect your non-existant upload limit. What ticked Wypatroszony off is that you bypassed the queue even though image quality was kind of questionable - just use that "upload for approval" in the future when you're not sure, and no one's gonna say anything.

Type-kun said:

The single comment suggesting to give you a negative feedback was done by a Member-level user, which can't even give you one - I think they was just adding fuel to fire, some people find that fun. Aside from that, you'll have no side-effects even if all those flagged images will get deleted, as it won't affect your non-existent upload limit. What ticked Wypatroszony off is that you bypassed the queue even though image quality was kind of questionable - just use that "upload for approval" in the future when you're not sure, and no one's gonna say anything.

Sure, I just "kinda" forgot about it. I'll be sure to check it next time I found an artist with questionable characters' anatomy and proportion style of drawing.

I'm not sure what the hell happened there.

Not_One_Of_Us said:

I'm not sure what the hell happened there.

Okay, what happened is: Somehow I found dupp_akiru on Pixiv, and upload his works here on Danbooru. But I did that using my position as a Contributor to bypass the moderation queue, even when some of the artist's works are kinda questionable in the anatomy and proportion department. That ticked the Janitor, Wypatroszony off, so he flagged the images that he's deemed as "awful", but he never gave any reasonable reasons for the flagging, and kinda aggressive about it too.

Then, in one of his reason for flagging them stuff, in post #1813942, he's suddenly dragged Not_one_of_us name out, since he think if you see these kind of stuff, you'd think twice before approving more "trash" like them, like you always do.

How passive-aggressive!

Stan-Miller said:

when some of the artist's works are kinda questionable in the anatomy and proportion department.

To be fair, I would have absolutely zero consideration to upload these kind of posts. Perhaps he's ticked off not just because of the questionable art quality, but also the fact that it is Touhou on top of that?