Donmai

Comments

Blacklisted:
Show 9 more comments
[hidden]

LOTR3 said:

No, it’s actually quite terrible in both regards, video game insta-kill knives notwithstanding. It either takes six good hits to the chest, all the while struggling with the target and creating one hell of a mess, or a hard to line up stab between the first vertebrae and the skull to sever the spinal column from the brain. The first isn’t that quiet or quick and the second is finicky at best. At that range, why not just dome them with a silenced .22lr pistol like the Welrod or a Ruger? Hell, a garrotte would be better than a knife, you’ve still got a struggle but there’s almost nothing the victim can do except gasp for air. My point is that knives are the meme weapon of stealth that should never be considered unless they are literally the ONLY THING you have on hand.

Ruger was founded in 1949 and as best I can find the lowest-caliber Welrod was chambered for .32 ACP, besides which a .22 would have the same issues as a knife as far as needing precision to kill instantly. You're exactly right that a knife is only silent if you get it right the first time, but A: it's a tool that's useful for things other than stealthy kills as well and thus a better use of a human's limited carrying capacity, and B: the SAS trained like madmen so that they would get it right the first time.

  • 4
  • Reply
  • [hidden]

    AlsoSprachOdin said:

    Really? I'd think a club would in fact be quicker and quieter. And wouldn't rely on hitting the heart.

    A club is quite big, long, cumbersome, heavy and requires lots of strength to be lethal. You want to unalive the enemy, not knock them out.

  • 1
  • Reply
  • Show 6 more comments
    [hidden]

    darkspire91 said:

    If the range of those railguns are anything to go by, battleships won't either.

    True...

    Then again, Hood may be a little biased due to some memories of getting an incredibly unlucky hit in a critical area that made her go boom.

    Also... am I the only one who realizes that this rigging would be perfect for Battleship Kaga to get along with Akagi-chan?

  • 3
  • Reply
  • [hidden]

    Eboreg said:

    "Some soulless blip on the radar"? She does realize that at that range, radar will get blocked by the horizon and you're going to need aircraft on scene to guide the projectile in?

    This is regarding Hood mistaking Prinz Eugen for Bismarck. This actually happened at the Battle of the Denmark Strait, and what I was referencing here. This is why Hood looks away in that panel (several of the folks on reddit caught this.) Hood's in-game quotes reference this is well.

    I've been a very serious student of WWII history for a long, long time and nothing makes me happier than after adding an obscure (to the casual) tidbit of historical truth to my work here and within seconds of posting a new comic, several folks post replies with "I know what that is!" Good stuff.

  • 6
  • Reply
  • [hidden]

    Eboreg said:

    True...

    Then again, Hood may be a little biased due to some memories of getting an incredibly unlucky hit in a critical area that made her go boom.

    Also... am I the only one who realizes that this rigging would be perfect for Battleship Kaga to get along with Akagi-chan?

    Just throwing this out there, as I'm a bit of a proponent for nuclear power, but a nuclear reactor doesn't go 'boom' when bad things happen. It can't go boom, the fuel isn't enriched enough.

  • 2
  • Reply
  • [hidden]

    Armathos said:

    Just throwing this out there, as I'm a bit of a proponent for nuclear power, but a nuclear reactor doesn't go 'boom' when bad things happen. It can't go boom, the fuel isn't enriched enough.

    nuclear reactors CAN go boom just look at chernobyl

  • -1
  • Reply
  • [hidden]

    blaze6909 said:

    nuclear reactors CAN go boom just look at chernobyl

    Chernobyl was using a flawed reactor and one can look to SEVERAL other examples of Nuclear power that did not explode (the reactors aboard the russian submarine Kursk being a perfect example.)

    Most reactors in a military setting are built with the intent to make them manageable in the event of damage or possible melt down, or so I would hope

  • 0
  • Reply
  • Show 10 more comments
    [hidden]

    hunter81095 said:

    Except "she" is the correct pronoun for Bismark, despite what that idiot of a captain thought. He believed that Bismarck should be considered male because she was the most powerful battleship Germany ever made despite the fact that there were at least EIGHT battleships in the world that had more firepower, and most of those also had radar that didn't get ruined when the rifles fired.

    So no, Bismarck is a she, not a he.

    Bismarck, like every ship ever built anywhere, is an inanimate object. It is not a he, nor a she, it is a THING.

  • -12
  • Reply
  • [hidden]

    Armathos said:

    Bismarck, like every ship ever built anywhere, is an inanimate object. It is not a he, nor a she, it is a THING.

    Ships have always historically used female pronouns and that trend continues today. Try having this argument with real sailors and see how much they care.

  • 10
  • Reply
  • [hidden]

    blindVigil said:

    Ships have always historically used female pronouns and that trend continues today. Try having this argument with real sailors and see how much they care.

    Which would only show how some people are stupidly attached to inanimate objects as if they were alive.

    We play a game that makes characters out of these ships because it's fun and yostar can relatively easily write amusing or interesting scenarios based on their service histories.

  • -12
  • Reply
  • [hidden]

    Armathos said:

    Which would only show how some people are stupidly attached to inanimate objects as if they were alive.

    We play a game that makes characters out of these ships because it's fun and yostar can relatively easily write amusing or interesting scenarios based on their service histories.

    Considering that ship is the only thing between you and a watery grave, it made sense for sailors to treat their vessels with the utmost respect. Treating them like a lady one might say.

    That tradition continues even today, with very few languages making the exception. Ships are either women or gendered after who they're named after.

  • 10
  • Reply
  • [hidden]

    Vegeta002 said:

    More likely "Bismarck", the Sabaton song about how awesome the Bismarck was.

    Which actually kinda makes me wonder how AL Bismarck feels about the real world Bismarck being male, making her one of the only known genderswapped characters.

    Eh, that's a point of contention. As far as it is to my knowledge only two people ever called IRL Bismarck male during that time; the ship's CO and the CO of the submarine U-556. Everyone else both their crews and elsewise called her "she". This of course excludes Naval Historians and Sabaton's retellings of those two men, has referred to Bismarck as the traditional "she" across the board.
    Personally I side with maintaining her as herself due to the alleged reasoning of the COs for calling Bismarck "him" just being a pitiful attempt to somehow snub Hitler, as opposed to trying to make any noble statements regarding naval ship naming conventions or really anything else really naval related. The part that actually matters for ship's.
    I don't mind bucking traditional conventions if there is a sound reasoning for doing so, however being politically petty isn't sound, it's just sad.

    Updated

  • 0
  • Reply
  • 1 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83