translation: asset #20720579
Context:
Ado's Shinzou performance featured a surprise guest appearance by Miku.
They performed a brand new song: 桜日和とタイムマシン ("Sakura Biyori to Time Machine" / "Cherry Blossom Weather and Time Machine")
written by Mafumafu (previously collabed with Ado on Kokoro to Iu Na no Fukakai)
with Miku tuned by Mitchie M (previously collabed with Ado on All Night Radio)
(Both have an extensive history as Vocaloid producers.)
Maiden_in_Orange said:
I just tagged it original and ai-generated art (topic) to indicate the situation. Not sure if derivative work is applicable here, but I think it is (as it's literally a redraw of an AI-gen Touhou sprite.
That's great. Derivative does fit definition wise
If the Touhou generator was used as a source of inspiration for this and this is fully or mostly human-drawn, then this should be tagged ai-assisted.
However it looks and sounds like this is a direct product of the generator itself, in which case it should be tagged ai-generated and deleted.
Either case, this is misuse of the ai-generated art (topic) tag.
Arcana55 said:
If the Touhou generator was used as a source of inspiration for this and this is fully or mostly human-drawn, then this should be tagged ai-assisted.
However it looks and sounds like this is a direct product of the generator itself, in which case it should be tagged ai-generated and deleted.
Either case, this is misuse of the ai-generated art (topic) tag.
How did you come to the conclusion that this was ai-generated? From an artist that has never generated anything before or after this (that we know of), looks like the rest of the artist's stuff around that time, and was posted in response to a challenge to "draw these funny generated touhous"?
Arcana55 said:
However it looks and sounds like this is a direct product of the generator itself, in which case it should be tagged ai-generated and deleted.
The Twitter post is from 2021-12-13[1]. Stable Diffusion was released in August 2022[2][3]. Find me a model from late 2021 that can generate images as coherent and consistent with the artist's usual style as this post.
Updated
ehh said:
The Twitter post is from 2021-12-13[1]. Stable Diffusion was released in August 2022[2][3]. Find me a model from late 2021 that can generate images as coherent and consistent with the artist's usual style as this post.
Encountering this post under ai-generated art (topic) tag along with posts like post #7486384 and post #7486418, along with the previous discussion here, I came to the conclusion that this post was associated with the hashtag "#aigeneratedtohou" as well, without the obvious redrawing those other posts have. Given the original tweet date you mention, that was clearly a mistake on my part.
Still, that makes the ai-generated art (topic) tag even more wrong.
Arcana55 said
Still, that makes the ai-generated art (topic) tag even more wrong.
These drawings are literally redraws of ai-generated Touhou OCs. If anything, the idea of that tag not applying is absurd. They are undeniably within the scope of the tag. So unless you care to tell me how else one would be able to indicate that situation beyond ai-generated art (topic), then I'd like to ask you to quit making a fool of yourself in arguing against that tag's inclusion on a post that is literally a redraw of an ai-generated image, one of the main uses of the damn tag.
