Donmai

Comments

Blacklisted:
Date Uploader HeeroWingZero Rating General
Tags
doodlebird14 aldnoah.zero aoki_ryuusei_spt_layzner borderlands_(series) getter_robo getter_robo_(1st_series) ghost_in_the_shell gundam gundam_00 gundam_0080 gundam_00_a_wakening_of_the_trailblazer gundam_08th_ms_team gundam_build_divers gundam_g_no_reconguista gundam_tekketsu_no_orphans gundam_unicorn kidou_senkan_nadesico medarot mega_man_(classic) mega_man_(series) mega_man_4 mega_man_x_(series) megas_xlr mobile_suit_gundam neon_genesis_evangelion pacific_rim sakura_taisen seisenshi_dunbine soukou_kihei_votoms tengen_toppa_gurren_lagann titanfall_(series) titanfall_2 transformers transformers:_generation_1 virtual_on zeta_gundam zoids zoids_shinseiki/zero aestivalis blurr_(transformers) bt-7274 bumblebee_(transformers) claptrap deckerd dom_(mobile_suit) dunbine eva_00 eva_02 eva_08 fei-yen g-self getter-1 gipsy_danger gouf_custom gundam_dynames gundam_flauros gundam_harute gundam_kimaris_vidar gurren-lagann haro hyaku_shiki hygogg jegan_blast_master kg-6_sleipnir koubu kshatriya layzner liger_zero_schneider mega_man_(character) megas_xlr_(mecha) metabee optimus_prime pharaoh_man scopedog shockwave_(transformers) soundwave_(transformers) stark_jegan tachikoma vile_(mega_man) zaku_ii zaku_ii_s_char_custom absurdres character_request commentary english_commentary highres paid_reward_available 1girl 2boys android assault_visor axe blue_eyes color_wheel_challenge drill evangelion_(mecha) extra_eyes flame_print grey_background heart helmet holding holding_axe holding_sword holding_weapon horns humanoid_robot jaeger_(pacific_rim) mecha mecha_focus mobile_suit multiple_boys multiple_drawing_challenge one-eyed orange_eyes pink_eyes pixel_art red_eyes robot salute science_fiction shoulder_cannon super_robot sword thumbs_up titan_(titanfall) v-fin weapon yellow_eyes
[hidden]

blindVigil said:

That doesn't work if the thumbnails aren't what we see.

That... feels reductive, in this case.

One being that's not a condition for the pool, whose only rules state "If something strikes you as "clever", it goes here. This might be a witty visual pun, a savvy cross-reference, or just something really original." And this objectively is clever - it's using the thumbnail function on twitter to produce a composite image out of two thumbnails.

Two, there's plenty of images in the Clever pool where how it's clever needs to be explained. And there's at least one whole pool, Hilarious in Hindsight, where comments explaining why things should be in there is practically mandatory.

I can be brought around to the idea that Clever isn't the right pool for it, but not without some other pool or more unique tag used. Clever, Creative, the most tortured definition of Misleading Thumbnails? or some tag for decomposite images. Because it'd be a damn shame if this imageset didn't get the signal boost it deserved just because no single image qualifies on it's own.

I'd even be receptive to trying to edit the images to a version that matches the thumbnail so that can get the appropriate marker. We just should be able to do this art justice somehow.

  • 1
  • Reply
  • [hidden]

    Not everything belongs in a pool and the purpose of Danbooru is not to "do art justice" by treating pools and tags like awards. Pools do not exist for "signal boosting." By themselves these are completely normal looking images, only through Twitter's specific cropping do you see something special.

    That said, the correct tag for this, afaik, is thumbnail collage. We don't need to put every set of images like that into the Clever pool.

  • 2
  • Reply
  • 1 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35