Posted under General
Massonia said:
Is that a cum? if so I would re rate as E.
It’s implied, but I think there’s enough there to make a coy suggestion that is the porridge in front of her. Were it not for that there would be no question and it’d get an E. It’s the same as a woman eating a sandwich and spilling mayo on her chest.
I know sexually suggestive text is enough for S, but where does the boundary lie? The examples in forum #213388 seem more extreme than the posts in your milkers look heavy ma'am let me hold them (meme), but the latter seem like they should be rated S. The phrase "spank the Bocchi butt" in post #6561496 sounds like it should also qualify, but it sounds a bit less blatantly sexual (just a bit), so I'm not as sure about that one.
post #6850265 (Warning: Guro)
Uh...I have no idea if this should be S or Q because besides the one guro image, it is a pretty innocent collection of drawings of her (doesn't help it took me a sec to realize Hoojiro is holding her own intestines as opposed to being weirdly blood splattered there). I can see this being S instead of Q as I rated it, but I don't want to rate anything that undeniably needs the guro tag too low.
Maiden_in_Orange said:
post #6850265 (Warning: Guro)
Uh...I have no idea if this should be S or Q because besides the one guro image, it is a pretty innocent collection of drawings of her (doesn't help it took me a sec to realize Hoojiro is holding her own intestines as opposed to being weirdly blood splattered there). I can see this being S instead of Q as I rated it, but I don't want to rate anything that undeniably needs the guro tag too low.
A person holding their own bloody intestines in clear view should be rated E regardless of how innocent the rest of the image looks. Generally, exposed organs would merit a Q at minimum (such as in body horror).
Edit: @岩戸鈴芽, can you explain why you changed it back to Q? Is it because it is slightly ambiguous whether Hoojiro was actually disemboweled (for example, she may be holding someone else's organs)?
Updated
Blank_User said:
A person holding their own bloody intestines in clear view should be rated E regardless of how innocent the rest of the image looks. Generally, exposed organs would merit a Q at minimum (such as in body horror).
Edit: @岩戸鈴芽, can you explain why you changed it back to Q? Is it because it is slightly ambiguous whether Hoojiro was actually disemboweled (for example, she may be holding someone else's organs)?
I can't find the conversation currently, but after talking about it with some other users on the Discord we figured that Q was more appropriate. Like you said, it's definitely at least Q, but nothing straight up stood out as E, because of factors like the lack of explicit focus and the wound being completely obscured. This was taking into account both howto:rate and guro rating:q as well.
Visible organs out of their own body like that fall under the "extremely graphic violence" part of howto:rate, that pic should be rated E. Think about it this way: it's as explicit as guro can get. There's no hint of comedy, no surreal ambiguity, he's straight up holding his own guts.
How should post #3987163 be rated? howto:rate doesn't list anything about sex-related dialogue.
Aqros161 said:
How should post #3987163 be rated? howto:rate doesn't list anything about sex-related dialogue.
Guidelines for sex-related dialogue can be found in forum #213388, though it would be better for them to be listed in howto:rate. Basically, dialogue that can be understood by English speakers, including translated text, can affect the rating.
Regardless of the dialogue, the collar around the daughter's neck would make this at least S (BDSM is normally Q, but this is on the milder side). I'm not sure whether this combined with the dialogue is enough to elevate it to Q, but I'll keep it as is just in case and let someone else figure it out.
is that cameltoe? feel like it should be Q maybe
Campy00 said:
is that cameltoe? feel like it should be Q maybe
Yes, that is indeed a cameltoe. Honestly, considering how her legs are spread, how her pussy is barely covered by those undies, and how she's blushing, this feels too sexually charged for S. Feel free to add the cameltoe tag and rerate it to Q.
Is Sensitive okay for this? Her outfit is naturally pretty revealing.
G or S?
Maiden_in_Orange said:
G or S?
G IMO. Normally the skirt lift would be dubious, but it's very clear it's a layered outfit where the underlayer is meant to be shown here.
岩戸鈴芽 said:
G IMO. Normally the skirt lift would be dubious, but it's very clear it's a layered outfit where the underlayer is meant to be shown here.
That should actually be skirt hold I think
1123581321345589144 said:
Is Sensitive okay for this? Her outfit is naturally pretty revealing.
Borderline Q but yes, its S.
feels Q
Can't tell if this should be G or S, as she looks like she's jumping off a building. While my gut feeling is that G is more appropriate due to this only really being obvious upon closer observation, I'm not sure if the use of imminent suicide is enough to raise the rating by its very necessity (especially since the situation isn't at all comedic).
Maiden_in_Orange said:
Can't tell if this should be G or S, as she looks like she's jumping off a building. While my gut feeling is that G is more appropriate due to this only really being obvious upon closer observation, I'm not sure if the use of imminent suicide is enough to raise the rating by its very necessity (especially since the situation isn't at all comedic).
If you hadn't said that's what it looks like to you I wouldn't have seen it as that, so I'm also unsure about the application of imminent suicide. As for that tag, in most cases it should probably make something >S, barring comedic circumstances etc. like you mentioned.
Maiden_in_Orange said:
Can't tell if this should be G or S, as she looks like she's jumping off a building. While my gut feeling is that G is more appropriate due to this only really being obvious upon closer observation, I'm not sure if the use of imminent suicide is enough to raise the rating by its very necessity (especially since the situation isn't at all comedic).
I'd tag that G without a second thought.
