Are the covered nipples blatant enough for Q, or should it go in S instead?
Posted under General
Are the covered nipples blatant enough for Q, or should it go in S instead?
post #948830 and post #4501893
A little guro, but nothing sexual. Do they really count as Explicit?
ziin1234 said:
post #948830 and post #4501893
A little guro, but nothing sexual. Do they really count as Explicit?
Guro content (as used on Danbooru) should usually be E according to howto:rate. Sexual content is no longer the only factor used for ratings and does not need to be present for E if it is violent enough. That said, I did interpret it too broadly when I went through and rerated all of the posts with the guro tag and S rating a couple months ago (guro without sexual content used to be rated Safe), including the ones you are asking about. After looking at them a second time, I'm still leaning towards E for post #948830 (Q at minimum), but post #4501893 should definitely be lower, maybe as low as S. I rerated the latter as Q for now. We should also have a user with more familiarity with the guro tag determine whether the tag applies to these posts.
Blank_User said:
Are the covered nipples blatant enough for Q, or should it go in S instead?
I would say no, thats not Q.
This may be a stupid question since my pervious questions about nude cover and swimsuit posts were answered, but the back of a topless woman such as post #6464461 should be rated Q even if you can't see any breasts, right? I know some guidelines have exceptions, but I thought we're typically strict with visible nudity.
post #3449151 Implied sex, but nothing lewd is visible after the first panel (which still have them both fully clothed)
ziin1234 said:
post #3449151 Implied sex, but nothing lewd is visible after the first panel (which still have them both fully clothed)
That's literally still sex happening on screen, implied sex but unambiguously sex
I have this one rated as Q at the moment, but I'm not sure if that's the right rating for this one, as it isn't overtly gory, per say, but people are still clearly dead in this one. Is Q the right rating for this one?
post #6487956 Robot with breasts. Rating G or S?
Drimacus said:
post #6487956 Robot with breasts. Rating G or S?
It looks like she's wearing a skin-tight bodysuit, so probably S. I changed the rating just to be on the safe side.
Drimacus said:
post #6487956 Robot with breasts. Rating G or S?
rating guidelines on robots is vague afaik but imo those breasts look blatant enough for Q
Blank_User said:
Are you talking about the slight points on the breasts? Those are still allowed under S.
it's that and the breasts just really looking like bare breasts even if there are no nipples. Some other female robots' breasts still look like it's just breast-shaped metal plates but this one is more breast-like
I can't tell if this one is G or S. I have it as G right now, but her dress and posing are kinda suggestive to me...
Maiden_in_Orange said:
I can't tell if this one is G or S. I have it as G right now, but her dress and posing are kinda suggestive to me...
It's showing way too much skin, thats S
Back again, this time with one that isn't my own. I really think this one should be bumped up to Q or even E. I'm almost certain this is clothed sex happening. Also, there's a paid reward available where both characters are nude that would definitely get the E rating if it were uploadable. But I did wanna get a second opinion before I go changing the rating all willy-nilly first.
Updated
Maiden_in_Orange said:
Back again, this time with one that isn't my own. I really think this one should be bumped up to Q or even E. I'm almost certain this is clothed sex happening. Also, there's a paid reward available where both characters are nude that would definitely get the E rating if it were uploadable. But I did wanna get a second opinion before I go changing the rating all willy-nilly first.
It's 100% Q, she's gripping a suspiciously penis-sized and located bulge and his face is literally in her crotch. Please rerate that, and please smack anyone who tries to argue otherwise over the head.
BobTheBuilder_v1 said:
It's 100% Q, she's gripping a suspiciously penis-sized and located bulge and his face is literally in her crotch. Please rerate that, and please smack anyone who tries to argue otherwise over the head.
That's exactly what I thought. This was one of those that gave me pause when I saw it was rated S. I can only assume it was a misrate (as I've accidentally done before and had to go back and fix once I realized), because I have no idea how else you end up with that. Thanks for confirming my suspicions!
Maiden_in_Orange said:
That's exactly what I thought. This was one of those that gave me pause when I saw it was rated S. I can only assume it was a misrate (as I've accidentally done before and had to go back and fix once I realized), because I have no idea how else you end up with that. Thanks for confirming my suspicions!
the worst part is that it was first posted as G then someone had to rerate it to S