Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

andlabs

Failed appeal time, though I can understand why these would disinterest reviewers so I'm not particularly expecting to change anyone's mind here (except for the first one). All SFW.

post #8902948 - I see in past posts in this thread that 3D posts generally go unapproved (and I've avoided uploading BBBCC's 3D Koakumas and an old 3D Sumireko from my Telegram logs for that reason). Someone tagged this as 3D after I posted it; how can you tell? Is it just the fact the artist's other posts are 3D? I'm not sure a larger resolution version exists, but it certainly looks like it could be 2D to me. Or is it bad in some other way?

post #8905846 - Yes it's lineart but it's at least clever/funny???

post #8908118 - I can sort of see how this particular chibi style would be unappealing

post #8910229
post #8910230
post #8910233
post #8910392 - Set of four. Not sure what's wrong with these; the lining and shading seem good, anyway. The second one might have iffy projection issues, but the clear height difference in the first and fourth make me uncertain of that.

Thanks again!

Reply
Pecheneg ovs

To be honest, I don't really understand why the post #8837943 was deleted. It has a comparatively similar quality to my previous Works that were approved. May I ask to reconsider decision about this post? This is one of my best artworks and I would like people to be able to find it on the site using the necessary tags.

Reply
pablo.gonzales.2007

NeptuneStarPrime said:

Either it was noticeable or somebody just really likes overwatch instead

noticeable what? once again, i can't find a single mistake, well except that messy sketch on the background, but it's his kids' drawing, so it's supposed to be tolerable.

Reply
Nacha

NeptuneStarPrime said:

Either it was noticeable or somebody just really likes overwatch instead

Don't comment here, unless you're an approver or you want feedback to one of your uploads. It's just confusing for people who don't know how approval works.

pablo.gonzales.2007 said:

noticeable what? once again, i can't find a single mistake, well except that messy sketch on the background, but it's his kids' drawing, so it's supposed to be tolerable.

Ignore what the other user said. It's approved. Remember that the queue is over 1000 uploads strong and sometimes uploads are either bad or just not seen by the approver who would approve it.

Reply
1 519 520 521 522 523 524 525