Posted under General
Hello, Any reasons why these got deleted?
post #8898818 Seen by 3 approvers;post #8898851 Seen by 3 approvers;post #8898875 Seen by 6 approvers
Thanks for reviewing them.
Updated
post #8899390
Feedback on this one? Seen by only 5 approvers.
Edit: Thanks for the approval. But if possible, I really would like feedback on why the others disliked it.
Updated
Seriously, Lori Hagami's art has always gotten approved before.
What's wrong with this?
Hi, any feedback on why these posts weren't approved? Please give a second chance:
post #6584641
post #7738550
post #6147324
Updated
post #8875782
post #8852401
post #8832088
post #8682362
post #8682340
post #8682299
post #8682260
post #8682215
post #8682200
post #8682178
post #8682150
post #8682125
post #8682101
I am most curious about the first one, since art by the same artist has been approved once.
I had colored sketch I did of o.c. swordsman and thought it would help from getting deleted. Not sure if it was reviewed or not but did see 1 negative score. If deleted for reason would like feedback on what to improve in order to avoid deletion in future thanks. https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8429654?q=user%3Asicklebx
sicklebx said:
I had colored sketch I did of o.c. swordsman and thought it would help from getting deleted. Not sure if it was reviewed or not but did see 1 negative score. If deleted for reason would like feedback on what to improve in order to avoid deletion in future thanks. https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8429654?q=user%3Asicklebx
Self-uploads are always going to be hard, since you're always biased towards yourself. It used to be outright banned in the days of oldbooru, and is lowkey discouraged even now. I'd recommend a site like deviantart or pixiv instead for your uploads.
sicklebx said:
I had colored sketch I did of o.c. swordsman and thought it would help from getting deleted. Not sure if it was reviewed or not but did see 1 negative score. If deleted for reason would like feedback on what to improve in order to avoid deletion in future thanks. https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8429654?q=user%3Asicklebx
You said in the post commentary that this is your first time using these coloring and shading techniques, correct? It may be a decent attempt at that level, but your work is going to be compared with others made by artists that have spent years of experience perfecting their craft. Do a search for status:active approver:any to get an idea of the level Approvers expect.
The score isn’t considered when approving posts. Any member can upvote or downvote posts, not just Approvers.
The moderation history, which contain records of how many Approvers looked at a post and any reasons they gave, are cleared out after about a month has passed. Your upload was from three months ago. You should check your uploads promptly if the feedback is important to you.
Kinda curious about the fact that the parent and sibling uploads got approved while this one rejected. I'd appreciate any possible feedbacks or suggestions, thank you!
post #8904478
Similar condition for another post #8862255, but cannot appeal twice rn
Updated
Why all these pomepome1207's artworks (old post on Danbooru) was takedown? (not Deleted post by Approver check and not approve, but Deleted with Takedown with picture take out the site)
Updated
Blank_User said:
You said in the post commentary that this is your first time using these coloring and shading techniques, correct? It may be a decent attempt at that level, but your work is going to be compared with others made by artists that have spent years of experience perfecting their craft. Do a search for status:active approver:any to get an idea of the level Approvers expect.
The score isn’t considered when approving posts. Any member can upvote or downvote posts, not just Approvers.
The moderation history, which contain records of how many Approvers looked at a post and any reasons they gave, are cleared out after about a month has passed. Your upload was from three months ago. You should check your uploads promptly if the feedback is important to you.
right but it says that it was unapproved in three days does that mean it was not approved just the reason for it not being approved was deleted after a certain amount of time?
Ylimegirl said:
Self-uploads are always going to be hard, since you're always biased towards yourself. It used to be outright banned in the days of oldbooru, and is lowkey discouraged even now. I'd recommend a site like deviantart or pixiv instead for your uploads.
question? Is it a quality of your work? also how would you know before posting that it's worthy being on here? or should you just post and see what happens? And follow up which in your opinion works, best fanart that has characters that are copyrighted and established and widely known cause I mostly do oc's based on artists styles and sometimes my own originals.
NPEE2003 said:
Why all these pomepome1207's artworks (old post on Danbooru) was takedown? (not Deleted post by Approver check and not approve, but Deleted with Takedown with picture take out the site)
Looks like the posts were banned. Either they were paid rewards or the artist filed a DMCA request.
sicklebx said:
right but it says that it was unapproved in three days does that mean it was not approved just the reason for it not being approved was deleted after a certain amount of time?
Yes, that's how the modqueue works. Posts are given 3 days to be looked at by approvers before being deleted by default.
sicklebx said:
question? Is it a quality of your work? also how would you know before posting that it's worthy being on here? or should you just post and see what happens? And follow up which in your opinion works, best fanart that has characters that are copyrighted and established and widely known cause I mostly do oc's based on artists styles and sometimes my own originals.
Generally speaking, yeah. Danbooru is a curated image gallery that's based on the taste of the approvers. What you think might be quality might not be to the approvers. Simple pencil sketches almost never cut it, which you seemed to have realized (though it took you 8 years to do so). The fact that your most recent upload is a WMM-style making-of doesn't help much. Your art isn't bad (there's definitely been much worse self-uploads), it's just not up to the standards of Danbooru.
