Posted under General
sakuratwister said:
post #8242832 is not approved with the reason "Explicit porn is often held to a higher standard", but other works of the artist that are more NSFW such as post #7861962 have been approved and rest of a pinup nature are of similar quality.
How exactly is post #7861962, which only shows her topless, more NSFW than post #8242832, which has her genitals and anus on full display?
sakuratwister said:
post #8242832 is not approved with the reason "Explicit porn is often held to a higher standard", but other works of the artist that are more NSFW such as post #7861962 have been approved and rest of a pinup nature are of similar quality.
post #7861962 wasn't approved. It was uploaded by an unrestricted user who can skip the modqueue. If you believe it's low quality, flag it.
feedback please
Blank_User said:
How exactly is post #7861962, which only shows her topless, more NSFW than post #8242832, which has her genitals and anus on full display?
Apologies. I meant to say "also NSFW in nature" and have amended the message as such.
Would like feedback on this https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8268928 post #8268928
only reason given was "approvers did not like the post enough"
BronzePangolin said:
Would like feedback on this https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8268928 post #8268928
only reason given was "approvers did not like the post enough"
You should add an artist tag (see howto:artist for more information). I would raise your standards higher because it is lower on the quality side.
Hi, any feedback on why these posts weren't approved? Please give a second chance.
post #6247686
post #6244308
Updated
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8261758
Not entirely sure on this one, the parent was approved (Twitter) but the child (my post, Pixiv) hasn't been. Any ideas why?
I really have a big question regarding how hard it is to approve explicit images. Are any of these *NOT* good or do approvers just refuse to do the job.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8261863
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8258920
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8258278
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8258254
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8258229
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8254738
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8253096
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8253178
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8253330
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8258215
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8252553
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8202490
I have more in the deleted and am about to have even more from those that never get approved and are being put in the queue hell. More deletes and the account will simply get even less upload slots.
Updated
Nipples sure turn some approvers away regardless of quality.
post #8270210 (approved)
post #8270211 (deleted)
post #8270212 (approved)
post #8270214 (deleted)
Curious why these weren't approved. Any info for me to further improve what I pick to upload would be nice.
post #8266936
post #8266931 (parent post was approved)
post #6989851 (the quality looks same with other fanart from this artist that got approved)
elysialover said:
Nipples sure turn some approvers away regardless of quality.
post #8270210 (approved)
post #8270211 (deleted)
post #8270212 (approved)
post #8270214 (deleted)
Some approvers do hate explicit images even if they are really high in quality. If approvers approve images based on personal taste, then idk why should there be ones.
Even more uploads are gonna inevitably become deleted (or already have been by the time you reread this post)
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8270729
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8271057 (How is this good image did not getting approved is beyond my understanding)
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8271503
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8271823
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8271893
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8280249
Updated
KeepInTouch said:
Some approvers do hate explicit images even if they are really high in quality. If approvers approve images based on personal taste, then idk why should there be ones.
I just appealed one of the deleted post and this is the message I got
"Also nipples :/" "the bare breasts make it worse IMO".
Needless to say you were not kidding.
Updated
Crossland said:
I just appealed one of the deleted post and this is the message I got
"Also nipples :/" "the bare breasts make it worse IMO".
Needless to say you were not kidding.
This is embarrassing. An approver said to me before that I was making it worse by mocking them because they were already the butt of the jokes. Well, there is a reason for that. Approvers were mocked before I made the account and will still be mocked after a mod gets tired of me and decides to ban me if the flawed system remains.
Of course, what can you even expect from them when the approvers are the shitposters who keep undeleting garbage like this post #7412460 ? That nobody got demoted from that shows that the mods are also useless.
What's wrong with post #7811983 ? See? I am asking for feedback.
Updated
elysialover said:
Of course, what can you even expect from them when the approvers are the shitposters who keep undeleting garbage like this post #7412460 ? That nobody got demoted from that shows that the mods are also useless.
I have no words for this after looking at the mod history on that post.
I also have no words for the type of feedback being "breast and nipples are showing so it's bad" response.
Updated
Please keep your whining somewhere else or open another topic.
This topic is for asking for feedback, not a place for you to complain about the modqueue and approvers.
Stp_79 said:
Curious why these weren't approved. Any info for me to further improve what I pick to upload would be nice.
post #8266931 (parent post was approved)
Consider that the parent post is a complete different image.
Crossland said:
I just appealed one of the deleted post and this is the message I got
"Also nipples :/" "the bare breasts make it worse IMO".
Needless to say you were not kidding.
This seems to be a problem of not using enough words to make the meaning of the feedback clear. After looking at the post in question (post #8270214), I don't believe they meant "Nipples are showing, so it's bad" or "The fact that the breasts are bare makes it worse." They probably meant "The way the nipples are drawn make it look bad" and "The way the bare breasts are drawn makes it worse."
But let's say their reason for not approving it is completely stupid. It only takes one to approve a post (like this one was not too long ago), so it won't really hurt its chances too much. If a lot of Approvers look at it and pass it over, then there's a good chance there's an actual quality issue (or it's incredibly niche and/or off-topic). If only a few look at it, well... Approvers have lives outside of Danbooru, so there may be some days where a lot of good posts get passed over. Luckily, we do have some Approvers that will appeal such posts to give them another chance, or even approve posts that are no longer in the mod queue. If the post is good, it always has a chance.
would appreciate feedback on post #8260201 if possible
