Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

BulkyRab

I would like to have a little more feedback on these images since I appealed them and they were not approved
post #7101740
post #7100504

And i would also like to know if I can appeal them again after a while since I get the message that they can only be appealed once or if not I would like to know if I can somehow delete them so they are not limiting the images I can upload or they will just stay there without the possibility that I can do something?

pd:sorry if these doubts have already been answered before.

Reply
Blank User

BulkyRab said:

I would like to have a little more feedback on these images since I appealed them and they were not approved
post #7101740
post #7100504

And i would also like to know if I can appeal them again after a while since I get the message that they can only be appealed once or if not I would like to know if I can somehow delete them so they are not limiting the images I can upload or they will just stay there without the possibility that I can do something?

pd:sorry if these doubts have already been answered before.

As far as I know, everyone gets one, and only one, appeal for each post, and they can't ever get it back once they use it. However, if another user thinks it should be approved, they can appeal the post even if you already used yours. Also, even if your appeal fails and the post is no longer in the mod queue, the post can still be made active at any time if an approver or above comes across it and decides they like it enough.

There is no option to remove your uploads, not even media assets. Posts do not get permanently deleted from the site unless it is absolutely necessary (for example, if it contains illegal material). Your max upload count will eventually go back up as you upload more posts that get approved.

Reply
Blank User

Sessyoin_Kiara said:

Put more effort into tagging your posts, I ignore mintagged and mistagged posts.

Sorry, but why is that a factor? The tags are unrelated to the quality of the post, so I don't see why a lack of tags should prevent a post from being approved on its own. It's true the uploader should tag the post as thoroughly and accurately as possible, but any missing tags can always be added later. I would think the only exception to this would be the artist tag and the source.

Reply
Laudividni

Blank_User said:

Sorry, but why is that a factor? The tags are unrelated to the quality of the post, so I don't see why a lack of tags should prevent a post from being approved on its own. It's true the uploader should tag the post as thoroughly and accurately as possible, but any missing tags can always be added later. I would think the only exception to this would be the artist tag and the source.

Because it matters to me. The images are ok in my opinion and I'm sure I saw them in the modqueue at the time and moved to other posts because of the tagging. For context usually what I do is filter out posts I dislike, then I look for well tagged posts I might like and last, when I'm free to tag them, posts I might like that lack tags.

Reply
TDubz34

I posted a picture to Danbooru, and I saw that 12 out of 14 people gave it a positive review. Only 2 were negative from users with the name "hidden" which seems highly dubious. I get there's a "user protection" element at play, here. But come on. "Hidden?" Really? And 14 people favorited it. And the post was deleted because "10 or more people did not approve" of the picture.

Is the moderative review system even working when 12/14 people review a picture positively but it says they were all negative? Frankly, this feels like a broken and abusive system. And I'm not happy about it at all.

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7180846?q=user%3ATDubz34

This image has 5 positive and 2 negative reviews (again, by name "hidden" in red text). I'm expecting this one to get the same kind of BS "10 or more people" did not approve response at this point. So, I'm sharing it here just to be safe.

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7191165?q=user%3ATDubz34

Updated

Reply
Laudividni

TDubz34 said:

I posted a picture to Danbooru, and I saw that 12 out of 14 people gave it a positive review. Only 2 were negative from users with the name "hidden" which seems highly dubious. I get there's a "user protection" element at play, here. But come on. "Hidden?" Really? And 14 people favorited it. And the post was deleted because "10 or more people did not approve" of the picture.

Is the moderative review system even working when 12/14 people review a picture positively but it says they were all negative? Frankly, this feels like a broken and abusive system. And I'm not happy about it at all.

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7180846?q=user%3ATDubz34

This image has 5 positive and 2 negative reviews (again, by name "hidden" in red text). I'm expecting this one to get the same kind of BS "10 or more people" did not approve response at this point. So, I'm sharing it here just to be safe.

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7191165?q=user%3ATDubz34

Downvotes are anonymous and votes and favorites are meaningless for approval or disapproval. What you should look at is the message at the top of the image "It has been reviewed by X approvers. X did not like the post enough to approve it." or the moderation section of a post.

Only users above the Approver level can approve posts and only one approver is needed to approve a post. There are three default reasons for disapproval: breaks the rules, poor quality and disinterest. Approvers can add a message to detail the disapproval, like someone did in post #7180846. See about:mod_queue for more info.

Reply
1 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 487