Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

New year. new batch of artwork for review. First we have these three that i don't have much to say about besides feeling they're good quality.
post #7010401
post #6986334
post #7028845

These three are just okay in my opinion, but I feel like they're still good enough to be approved, and they serve to show how far the artist has come over the years when placed next to his later works.
post #7018244
post #7028840
post #7012074

Last and possibly least, I was hoping to hear opinions on this batch. Everything I've uploaded from this artist has ended up deleted, and I'm not sure why. The quality seems fine to me, aside from the uninteresting background, and their takes on classic kaiju is cool. Is the subject matter just not appealing?
post #7010638
post #6993096
post #6993068
post #6993031
post #6986573
post #6986511
post #6986462
post #6986587

Updated

QQWWU said:

Let me ask in advance, this post ( post #7044284) is 2.38 MB, but the size is the same as its son post( post #6726566)(522 KB), 1240x1754.
Does this mean it is basically impossible to pass?

The quality of the parent is superior. It has fewer jpg artifacts than the child post. That's the most likely reason why the file size is larger.

Thank you for your time in advance for reviewing this post!

post #6153999 was unapproved,
but matches the quality and cartoon style of post #5972890 by the same artist.

post #6156239 matches in style and quality of the other numerous approved uploads of this artist gabriel_ales.

Finally;
post #6997830 was unapproved with a comment 'Shading?' but the armor and chainmail are quite detailed.

post #6900375 matches in quality and style to the only other upload and approval from the same artist: post #6880632
Again thank you all for taking the time and consideration to review my post.

Noboriage said:

NSFW IMAGES

post #7024622
post #7024156
post #6923378

Was it the subject matter of the art that is the reason that this was not approved? This art is by the same artist, and quality-wise, it's fine art and even surpasses earlier approved art for this artist in terms of quality. Are approvers and moderators just less likely to approve of art dealing with bdsm/spanking/ryona and the like?

Me again, any answer for why these images are just not possible to pass? Many of this artists other work got approved and these are just good if not better in quality.

Noboriage said:

Me again, any answer for why these images are just not possible to pass? Many of this artists other work got approved and these are just good if not better in quality.

Most of those posts were approved automatically. The users that uploaded them were at least Contributor level at the time. Users at that level are allowed to skip the mod queue if they want to. This can occasionally result in active posts that are slightly lower in quality than what normally makes it through the mod queue. See help:users for more information.