Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

Jazarigi said:

post #6485354

new here so would like feedback on if i did anythin wrong :)

Not going to comment on the quality of the image since I'm not an approver, but I noticed you didn't tag the original artists on your uploads, don't forget to give them credit! If you aren't sure on what name to use because you're the first uploader of their work you can consult the artist help thread

Alright, honestly, I'm kinda baffled by this one.
I posted post #6511937, fully tagged, and it got rejected by 10/10 people who looked at it. Yet post #6560003, who is by all means similar, got approved.

Can somebody give me an explanation of why this happened? I'd say the pic is not bad quality and I'm happy the other one got accepted, but frankly, I want to understand where I went wrong.

Duck8978 said:

Alright, honestly, I'm kinda baffled by this one.
I posted post #6511937, fully tagged, and it got rejected by 10/10 people who looked at it. Yet post #6560003, who is by all means similar, got approved.

Can somebody give me an explanation of why this happened? I'd say the pic is not bad quality and I'm happy the other one got accepted, but frankly, I want to understand where I went wrong.

The second post you linked was not "approved". The uploader does not have to go through the queue and have an approver look at and accept their post when uploading because they are a Contributor. See the wiki page on Users if you're still confused.

lyenin said:

post #6551664post #6551655post #6551656
tell me why? tag or artist?

You didn't put effort into tagging the posts and I wouldn't say they're low quality, but the reason for me is the fetish content. The first one has an oversized penis.

minnazzo said:

Please give me some reasons why these weren't approved, especially the 1st, 2nd and 3rd one. I say they're not of bad quality.
post #5469805
post #6552440
post #6557652
post #6566998
post #6567654

- Idk where you got that .png from.
- I rarely upload and probably rarely will approve monochrome sketchy artworks, one of the girls has a small hand and the other a weird foot imo.
- Idk what that is, but I consider that to be of poor quality.
- It's still in the queue, I see that's the two layers of the parent's first panel, but I don't read that comic.
- It's still in the queue, looks like a cropped image with a bar censor over the speech bubble in the left. I'm not a big fan.

Bad tagging won't make people skip posts - I think - but you should tag your uploads better instead of relying on *request tags. There are no blonde hair and pig in post #6567654.