Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

richie said:
Weird proportions and/or perspective

For me her legs looks a little bit unnatural. I say these kind of pictures are on the verge of approval. They are not particularly bad, but they're not especially good or interesting either. Bad luck this time, I guess.

The proportions (specifically her legs) aren't that dissimilar from her official art, namely post #62445. In fact, they're pretty faithful to her original/official appearance, IMO. Breast size aside, anyway.

Also, if post #1051172 has a "weird" perspective, wouldn't just tagging it dutch_angle satisfy the concern?

The UI, and being a game cg probably didn't help.

Everything taken into consideration, I don't see how it is any worse than post #577565

It's a screenshot from a game executable that isn't even ran in the proper language locale, and "there is worse art on the site" is not justification for appealing even if it was extracted from the game data directly and uploaded.

post #1069478
Is it the odd style?

My deleted posts just keep going up & up...

Greetings.
So, the time for me to post here has "finally" come.
Every time I see my post deleted, I try finding a reason by myself. And I have doubts for at least 15 out of 30 of the deleted, but since I don't want the thread to clog up, I'll restrain myself to 5 entries per forum post; that might happen in the closer or further future.

post #1051506 and it's parent. I believe it's the floor, which led to deletion. But does it have such a heavy impact?
post #1053345. Bad proportions, shading or both?
post #1055073. Not the faintest idea what's wrong in here.
post #1055533. No general idea. Maybe it's the composition, but I'm not sure.
post #1055717. Shope took the faces of Nazrin's and Kyouko's too far off?

I'm sorry it resulted in the post being still this big. I hope to receive some feedback and be a bit more sure.
Thanks in advance for your patience.

As far as I can tell:

- Bad anatomy (Thighs don't work that way)
- Bad anatomy (proportions of arms and bad feet)
- Bad hands
- Bad anatomy (legs not the same size, cylinder arms, the body isn't fleshed out)
- Seems to be the face. This isn't as egregiously misshapen as the four other posts. I think it deserves approving, although if it has another problem, I didn't catch it glancing over the post.

• post #1051506: Yes, thighs/hips. Also odd proportions with the huge head but not chibi proportions.
• post #1053345: Agree with Aristocrat.
• post #1055073: Bad hands and face.
• post #1055533: Legs, arms, face, neck.
• post #1055717: Nazrin’s and Mamizou’s faces look odd, bad ears for Nazrin, loooong necks, sloppy lines (sketchy) and coloring (outside the lines, see Kyouko’s right hand and bottom of her dress).

kittey said:
loooong necks

CANNOT UNSEE

I don't think holding images to the standards of not having "Sloppy lines" is a good idea, though, considering that oekaki is deemed danbooru-worthy. If the entire image is drawn that way, it's not much of a problem visually.

Aristocrat said:
I don't think holding images to the standards of not having "Sloppy lines" is a good idea, though, considering that oekaki is deemed danbooru-worthy. If the entire image is drawn that way, it's not much of a problem visually.

Depends on whether the image is fine. If it has good anatomy, proportions, etc., I’d let it slide. However, if not, it’s another minus point of a mediocre or low-effort image that’s far from the high quality that Danbooru aims for.

Edit: Apologies for straying off-topic.

Not what this thread is for, man.

Could be the wrong thread for my request but I didn't find a fitting one.

post #1050331, uploaded by pikuchan. It's Pixiv 1000 and a dream for every Naruto fan. So... Why is this not approved?

I always wondered why post #766169 and post #766172 has not been accepted.

They are beautiful, high res and, at least at the time of posting, fairly difficult to find on the Internet at so high resolution and without watermarks.

Beside post #766168 has been accepted, it is arguably the most beautiful of the three. But still it seems strange to me.

Stefan86 said:
post #1050331, uploaded by pikuchan. It's Pixiv 1000 and a dream for every Naruto fan. So... Why is this not approved?

I don't know what every Naruto fan dreams about, but this art is mediocre at best, with proportions/perspective problems (compare their lower and upper body parts).

etb said:
I always wondered why post #766169 and post #766172 has not been accepted.

They are off topic. Some good quality, off topic pictures still might get accepted, but don't take this for granted.

I really would like to have feedback for the following posts, drawn by paychflat. Is there something taboo about this artist?

post #1078933
post #1078927
post #1078931

post #1081681

Can someone explain to me why this was never approved?

ETA: post #659157 too while I'm here. :/

What's wrong with these? All are safe and IMO are very well-drawn.

post #1066040
post #1073662
post #1066669
post #1066670
post #1066656
post #1064187
post #1073660
post #998551

jjj14 said:
What's wrong with these? All are safe and IMO are very well-drawn.

post #1066040
post #1073662
post #1066669
post #1066670
post #1066656
post #1064187
post #1073660
post #998551

Bad facial composition and boring CG mostly.

Requesting feedback about:
post #1055807
post #1056376
post #1059324
post #1059329
post #1062838

Seems good enough to deserve double-check...

post #1093694
I know it probably wasn't approved because of Annyui's relatively crude art style but most his other works have been approved. Personally, I think that his series of Touhou kindergarteners is something worth having here.

post #1093070
No idea why this wasn't approved especially since post #1093067 was.

post #1094936
I understand Homare (suzu no oka) is pretty borderline around here but things like post #941511 (explicit/urine) have still been approved.