Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

Unbreakable said:

The parent was uploaded but an unrestricted user (me) so it didn't have to be approved. Also, you shouldn't post stuff here that's still pending since there's a chance it'll be approved still.

Well, i asked a Moderator, he told me to ask it here, so hence why i asked it here.

dikkun11037 said:
post #3495839

Really thin waist. I know that's in line with the official style, but the rest of picture isn't - and the mismatch doesn't really work that well. Even discounting that the image is pretty average.

dikkun11037 said:
post #3495209

It's a little bit sketchy and blurry in places - but I think those are within parameters. Honestly I probably would have let this through.

dikkun11037 said:
post #3495292

One of the feet is slightly odd, but I also don't think that's enough to pass it over. I'd put this one at a solid borderline too. Male focus unfortunately doesn't grab as much attention.

忍猫 said:

post #3391936

I honestly wasn't able to tell why this was considered poor quality. It's cute, no flaws in the anatomy, and looks very similar and if not better than similar posts such as post #2473700.

It looks very scribbly and rough, with colors going over lines, which isn’t that popular. Unevenly lighted photographs of drawings don’t look that appealing either, IMO. Personally, I don’t like the stars, which look like they were added digitally, clashing with the traditional media look.

post #2473700 on the other hand looks a lot cleaner and nothing clashes with each other.

kittey said:

It looks very scribbly and rough, with colors going over lines, which isn’t that popular. Unevenly lighted photographs of drawings don’t look that appealing either, IMO. Personally, I don’t like the stars, which look like they were added digitally, clashing with the traditional media look.

post #2473700 on the other hand looks a lot cleaner and nothing clashes with each other.

I see where you're coming from. Thanks for the feedback!

Uzimaki-BE said:

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/3498992

I wonder why this one got rejected.

  • Wonky face with facial features that look like her head is tilted but her jawline and chin suggest that it’s straight.
  • Arms are bent tubes with no actual elbow or shoulder joints.
  • Zero-effort pussy. If the artist couldn’t or didn’t want to draw one, some convenient censoring would’ve been better. Otherwise, reference images aren’t exactly hard to find on the Internet.
  • Inconsistent shading. Where’s the light source(s) supposed to be?

Ugh, looks like these are common issues with this artist.