Donmai

Rifyu

Posted under General

This topic has been locked.

Miles-chan

Seriously, if you don't like her work just DON'T SEE IT. You can't just prevent people to see things they like because you don't like it. I have seen a lot of things here I didn't like and I thought they were "unfunny" and "terribly drawn", and even if I could I wouldn't delete it because there are people who actually like it.
I hope you get a life and stop doing things just because you can. :)

Saladofstones

葉月 said:
Christ, this thread has devolved completely. I'll be locking it now, think what you want about my fascist practices.

YagamiShinji: if you still have problems, make a new thread and/or send me a dmail, whichever you prefer.

What kind of reaction did you honestly expect? I don't want to single you out for this, but this type of thing is going to cause massive amounts of problems and locking the thread on top of that is only going to make this worse.

DUHEED

葉月 said:
Are you undeleting it because you think they have a place here, or just because you disagree with how it was done?

I'd say the burden of proof is on you to explain why they don't have a place here.

葉月

albert said:
Next time you want to delete 193 images, many of them with notes, please allow at least 3-4 days for people to argue.

Btw, since you seem to have time to micromanage now, could you please look at the important tasks like http://trac.donmai.us/ticket/1257? They are hurting the ability to moderate actual problems, such as spoilers, effectively (and fairly).

Pikmin

DUHEED said:
I'd say the burden of proof is on you to explain why they don't have a place here.

That is a really good point, DUHEED. I want an explanation too. But a real one. Not: "Bad draw style, horrible jokes. Me do not like. Me delete."

Thank you so much, Albert! You are our hero!

Saladofstones

evazion said:
Someone on /jp/ was butthurt that he flagged post #856283. Things spiralled from there: http://archive.easymodo.net/cgi-board.pl/jp/thread/6981760.

I have to say that this was not carried out well. But most of the issue is that "deleting fucking everything because I don't like it, and too bad if you don't like it" type attitude expressed on /jp/ is not going the way to handle something like this diplomatically.

I never liked his stuff, but this was poorly handled. I'm not going to drag Hazuki's name through the mud but this was a bizarre situation made worse by not considering how people may react to this. It was a hasty decision with consequences and its going to hang over people's head for awhile because of how prone the internet is to drama.

But I'm going to make a separate thread just to discuss the comic and if it should be kept on the site, and make it a separate issue from whether or not the deletion was warranted, which is where this thread is at.

reese

As a user who doesn't follow anything related to umineko no naku koro ni including these comics, I don't have any real attachment to them.

However, I believe albert's undeletion of the posts is the correct one. Now we can have proper discussion about the artist. Users can now browse and read these comics and discern whether or not they are funny. His style is certainly crude but it is his own.

Saladofstones

Kyousuke-kun said:
The point is that there isn't in Danbooru upload rules anything like:

"Just upload funny and well-drawed images"

Its like Bkub. You love it or you hate it, or completely indifferent. The difference is that Riyfu is a bit more crude but I don't think it doesn't have redeeming qualities.

richie

parasol said:
Member-level accounts can't do this.

As a member you can always comment (and bump) such post.
If your reasons are valid, then it has very high chance to be noticed and flagged by someone who can do it.

Pikmin

Anelaid said:
Its like Bkub. You love it or you hate it, or completely indifferent. The difference is that Riyfu is a bit more crude but I don't think it doesn't have redeeming qualities.

As just said later, Rifyu's comics are drawn badly on purpose. The style is called "heta uma", or "bad/good". So, this isn't a good reason for nuking it.

Again, 葉月's opinion was thoughtless and imature. In this topic about "Bad Drawing" I think he failed for simply don't know about diferent types of art.

The fun on Rifyu's 4koma is simply the jokes and HetaUma. If you don't know, me and my friends have a lot of Rifyu's emoticon because the bad drawing is funny.

Everyone has a diferent perspective for see something. But it's wrong let this one perspective control general situation in some subject.

user 322562

葉月 said:
Are you undeleting it because you think they have a place here, or just because you disagree with how it was done?

Not that I'm speaking for Albert or anything, but I'm going to assume that he undeleted them because of HOW you did it. He did give some explanation in his post you quoted.
After all the bitching done to you, I think you should just take the advice so this problem doesn't happen again.

1 2 3 4