Posted under General
I agree with following the same practice as the Umineko example. I think it's the most apt comparison one could make here, given just how heavily Avemuji is inspired by certain aspects of Umineko specifically, like... I really don't think it can be denied. No complaints from me, though.
Updated
CoreMack said:
Out of all the options I think my preference would be for Misumi Uika's sister. That's the least spoilery name for it, since there's plenty of tags out there like that for side characters without actual names.
On the incest issue, I'm torn. On one hand, it is definitely incest. TWYS has no application to family relations tags, those are always tagged canonically. They're related, pictures of them fucking are pictures of incest, and they should be tagged as such.
On the other hand, there's very significant spoiler concerns. There are also a solid 600 posts, uploaded prior to the reveal, that we would need to go back and tag as incest, when the artist at the time had no idea they were drawing incest and none of the fans saw it as incest.
I tend to prefer the latter, mainly due to the spoiler issue. Any post specifically referencing incest should be tagged as such plus spoilers. Posts like post #9068565 that reference "Hatsune" should also be tagged spoilers.
ANON_TOKYO said:
Misumi Uika's sister (which I see you've made by now) seems good to me, it's neutral enough. I'm also still on board with the described approach w.r.t. gentags. As you said, those old works weren't drawn with incest in mind with both the artist and the audience, which just adds to the downsides of applying it broadly.
Then how does one use aunt_and_niece with all this?
AbsoluteRainbow said:
Then how does one use aunt_and_niece with all this?
aunt and niece should be used the exactly same as incest, for the same reasons (i.e. don't tag it for now, unless there's a specific reference to it).
