Imply Archerko to Illya

BUR #35542 has been rejected.

create implication archerko_(himura_kiseki) -> illyasviel_von_einzbern

Archerko is Illya as a Counter Guardian

Vastly different appearance and functionally non-canon variant.

Ylimegirl said:

Vastly different appearance and functionally non-canon variant.

It still IS Illya though, so should be implied, canon or not.

Witch-Hunter-Siegfried said:

It still IS Illya though, so should be implied, canon or not.

Tags are supposed to help search for a character. Archerko's design is different from canon Illya. If I am searching for illyasviel von einzbern, I'm not searching for Archerko.

Let's take this from another angle.
Should Archer_(fate) imply Emiya Shirou?
They are both the same character, technically.
However their designs and personalities are very different. If I'm searching for Shirou, I'm not searching for Archer. Same goes the other way around.

Login_to_view said:

Tags are supposed to help search for a character. Archerko's design is different from canon Illya. If I am searching for illyasviel von einzbern, I'm not searching for Archerko.

Let's take this from another angle.
Should Archer_(fate) imply Emiya Shirou?
They are both the same character, technically.
However their designs and personalities are very different. If I'm searching for Shirou, I'm not searching for Archer. Same goes the other way around.

I think I did the wrong thing then, I meant to have it be a subtag of Illya (IDK the term, where if Archerko is tagged Illya will appear above it ) I haven't dicked with them too much so might have fucked it up. The Archer Shirou thing TBF is a twist while this isn't so that is a difference.

Witch-Hunter-Siegfried said:

I think I did the wrong thing then, I meant to have it be a subtag of Illya (IDK the term, where if Archerko is tagged Illya will appear above it ) I haven't dicked with them too much so might have fucked it up. The Archer Shirou thing TBF is a twist while this isn't so that is a difference.

An implication would accomplish that, but I dont think it makes sense to create an implication for effectively someone's OC to a canon character.

Both chloe_von_einzbern and sitonai_(fate) are technically Illya but are treated as separate characters. I don't see any reason why Archerko should be any different.

The bulk update request #35542 (forum #330741) has been rejected by @evazion.