Donmai

Dungeon Meshi Chartag Implications

Posted under Tags

BUR #24475 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication falin_thorden_(tallman) -> falin_thorden
create implication falin_thorden_(chimera) -> falin_thorden
create implication marcille_donato_(lord) -> marcille_donato

These should be implied just like any other character subtags. Now that we have nested chartag implications, it just looks wrong to see these tags next to each other, not nested.

These ones are the bigger tags that should be uncontroversial.

BUR #24476 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication falin_thorden_(doll) -> falin_thorden
create implication marcille_donato_(half-foot) -> marcille_donato
create implication marcille_donato_(scylla) -> marcille_donato
create implication marcille_donato_(oni) -> marcille_donato
create implication laios_thorden_(dog) -> laios_thorden
create implication laios_thorden_(chimera) -> laios_thorden
create implication laios_thorden_(dwarf) -> laios_thorden
create implication chilchuck_tims_(tallman) -> chilchuck_tims
create implication senshi_(half-foot)_(dungeon_meshi) -> senshi_(dungeon_meshi)
create implication senshi_(elf)_(dungeon_meshi) -> senshi_(dungeon_meshi)
create implication kabru_(elf) -> kabru
create implication izutsumi_(kobold) -> izutsumi

Smaller tags that we may or may not think deserving of an implication.

I'm not 100% sure we need all these tags at all, to be honest, but if we have them then they should be nested like the other tags.

BaiserLaVerite said:

I don't understand why Falin needs a tallman tag, when that's her default form, and unlike the others, she never participated in changeling shenanigans.

I made it because her posts are more evenly split between her forms, and they're significantly different designs.

I'm ok with having a tag for her original form. It's not unprecedented to do that when a character's specific form makes up a significant portion of their posts. Falin also technically has three forms, if we consider the one after the transformation's reverted and falin_touden_(doll), so it's not as easy as just excluding the Chimera tag.

Speaking of that, I'm wondering however if we should have an additional, separate tag for her hybrid form after the transformation's reverted. Talking about things like post #7337583 or post #7331473.

BUR #28069 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication laios_touden_(gnome) -> laios_touden
create implication chilchuck_tims_(dwarf) -> chilchuck_tims
create implication izutsumi_(orc) -> izutsumi

A few others that were missing.

By the way, might be a dumb question but should we make/keep specific character tags for forms that were shown in side materials but didn't appear in the main story (Demon King Laios, Elf Falin and Gnome Marcille to name a few)? Seeing as they're effectively non-canon... I don't know what's the exact stance on that.

For what it's worth, if Demon King Laios gets to keep his character tag, I think the others deserve their own too. We'll often have to check for implications though.

1