Donmai

Create a FUWAMOCO general tag

Posted under Tags

LQ

BUR #24297 has been rejected.

mass update fuwawa_abyssgard mococo_abyssgard -> fuwamoco

Adds a fuwamoco general tag to all posts that feature both fuwawa abyssgard and mococo abyssgard, the duo that makes up FUWAMOCO. This includes posts that also have other characters.

Both twins have roughly the same number of posts and appear in 84% of them together. There isn't even an official Twitter art hashtag for the individual members.

I think it would make it a lot easier to search for posts that have both characters, similar to general tags that apply to posts featuring an entire generation/unit:

These tags are also sometimes used when all the groups' mascots appear. For fuwamoco, it would also simply apply when fuwawa abyssgard (dog) or mococo abyssgard (dog) appears with the other (incl. mixing girl–twin and dog–twin like in post #6560106; note that this post is only tagged mococo abyssgard (girl) because the dog is cosplaying). (As nice & convenient as it would be for it to be a character tag that implicates both, there's no precedent for that, it's not a character, and dogsona tags do not imply the characters.)

Or tags for other copyrights' idol units like:

While you could just search both character tags at once or something like *abyssgard or hololive twins (for now), there's nothing quite as intuitive as this.

Updated

Reply
LQ John Fantasy XIV Asht VR-Man sabisabi Cinnamon Toast zaregoto Red Terror Immersed Unbreakable blindVigil Mexiguy avidbookreader Laudividni TheGamingRodent
blindVigil

We don't make combo tags for a two tag search. Those hololive group tags exist because those groups have more than two members. Why do those other duo tags exist? The very first one looks like someone's pet tag.

Reply
LQ

blindVigil said:

We don't make combo tags for a two tag search.

Because dog tags don't implicate the character, it's actually equivalent to one of:

Sure, you can always save a bunch of characters with wildcards, but it's much more useful than just a two-tag search. An 8-character tag (or 3–5-character autocomplete) would be nice.

Updated

Reply
Mexiguy

The only possible use cases I can think for this tag would be to allow blue users to search for a character interacting with the pair e.g. nerissa_ravencroft fuwamoco instead of nerissa_ravencroft fuwawa_abyssgard mococo_abyssgard or to get a freebie tag when searching for the pair, but it would require lots of clauses in order to work, otherwise it would polluted and render useless (e.g. adding it to holoadvent would make the nerissa_ravencroft fuwamoco search 90% holoadvent posts, same with combinign it with any other tag.

Reply
blindVigil

LQ said:

Because dog tags don't implicate the character, it's actually equivalent to one of:

Sure, you can always save a bunch of characters with wildcards, but it's much more useful than just a two-tag search. An 8-character tag (or 3–5-character autocomplete) would be nice.

fuwawa_abyssgard_(dog) -fuwawa_abyssgard is a grand total of four posts out of 52. mococo_abyssgard_(dog) -mococo_abyssgard is three. It doesn't matter that they aren't implicated, because people still tag the main character tag. Any sensible person would expect animalizations to appear when searching for that character. There are animalization tags that implicate the original character (chen_(cat) is one), has anyone tried to implicate these tags? Or are we just assuming it wouldn't be approved?

None of that is a reason for a combo tag to exist, because it's concerned with a problem that doesn't actually exist.

I'm also going to assume that the only reason we have a bunch of duo tags for idol groups is because groups with more than two members have them, and "consistency" is at play.

Reply
1