On_* implications

BUR #23267 has been rejected.

create implication on_bench -> bench
create implication on_chair -> chair
create implication on_cloud -> cloud
create implication on_counter -> counter
create implication on_crescent -> crescent
create implication on_flower -> flower
create implication on_grass -> grass
create implication on_ladder -> ladder
create implication on_piano -> piano
create implication on_roof -> rooftop
create implication on_scooter -> scooter
create implication on_stool -> stool
create implication on_umbrella -> umbrella
create implication on_water -> water
create alias on_motorcycle -> on_vehicle
create alias on_scooter -> on_vehicle

I made a previous BUR that listed a few of these, but it was too big and included some entries that were better left as they are.
Here it's just implying the object that the on_* tag refers to. Currently, searching on_grass -grass returns 1945 results.

Linking the previous one for reference: topic #26204

BUR #23277 has been rejected.

create alias on_motorcycle -> on_vehicle
create alias on_scooter -> on_vehicle

-1
Should have been aliased instead. We do not use on_* for more types of vehicles furthermore. On_car was also aliased into on_vehicle.

GreyOmega said:
Conflating people operating vehicles with people just being atop a vehicle seems like a poor idea.

There's already riding or driving for that, more than just being on it.

World_Funeral said:

BUR #23277 has been rejected.

create alias on_motorcycle -> on_vehicle
create alias on_scooter -> on_vehicle

-1
Should have been aliased instead. We do not use on_* for more types of vehicles furthermore. On_car was also aliased for good.

I hadn't known. I added both of these into the BUR and removed the implication for on_motorcycle.

Rather than on_water, I think the tag should be on_liquid. While the current name is more intuitive, it excludes all posts where the character happens to be on something that isn't water, like blood or soda.

(Though perhaps this is a conversation for a different thread.)

World_Funeral said:

BUR #23277 has been rejected.

create alias on_motorcycle -> on_vehicle
create alias on_scooter -> on_vehicle

-1
Should have been aliased instead. We do not use on_* for more types of vehicles furthermore. On_car was also aliased for good.

Conflating people operating vehicles with people just being atop a vehicle seems like a poor idea.

This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 45 days.

The bulk update request #23267 (forum #268630) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 45 days.

The bulk update request #23277 (forum #268668) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.

A lot of these are questionable. on motorcycle is very different from standing on a car. For on water, see forum #275308. For on roof -> rooftop, what if we see a character on the roof but the pov is below and the roof is not actually seen?

This is why you shouldn't submit giant BURs like these.