Should an alt costume tag be made in this case?

I've been thinking of making a character tag and implication for Lady Phantomhive which is an official alternate costume of Ciel Phantomhive (To give an example of the design in question this is what it looks like: post #6015235, post #7126288, post #7182309, post #3479807). But at the same time I wanted to know if it's really necessary. I personally think it would make tagging and finding posts of the character in this costume easier just like how Zerochan has its own tag for this specific design. I'd like to hear opinions before making it since I'm not 100% sure when these type of tags should be made.

we already have alternate_costume tag, unless you mean something different here?

Massonia said:

we already have alternate_costume tag

I'm aware of that general tag as well as the one mentioned in OP, I'm referring to character costume tags like Toki (bunny) (blue archive) and Sakura Miko (school uniform) to name a few examples.

yeah you can make it with "char:character's name_(type the costume's name)_(copyright's name)"

I guess a tag for this outfit is fine for the same reasons we have Joseph Joestar (tequila).

Massonia said:

yeah you can make it with "char:character's name_(type the costume's name)_(copyright's name)"

It doesn't need the copyright qualifier if the original tag doesn't have one.

owh right my habit of giving AL costume name lol

I've made it as lady phantomhive although I'm not 100% sure if I should be using that name considering it's (afaik) unofficial, but it's the most popular name used to refer to this costume. If it needs to be changed to ciel_phantomhive_(crossdressing) or something like that I can make a BUR.

might need his name like what blindVigil post

Massonia said:

might need his name like what blindVigil post

So ciel_phantomhive_(lady_phantomhive) in that case?. I'm pretty sure the outfit itself doesn't have a canon name.

Jar_of_Flies said:

So ciel_phantomhive_(lady_phantomhive) in that case?

yes just like that

BUR #23161 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

rename lady_phantomhive -> ciel_phantomhive_(robin_dress)
create implication ciel_phantomhive_(robin_dress) -> ciel_phantomhive

Feel like this is necessary now

Jar_of_Flies said:

I've made it as lady phantomhive although I'm not 100% sure if I should be using that name considering it's (afaik) unofficial, but it's the most popular name used to refer to this costume. If it needs to be changed to ciel_phantomhive_(crossdressing) or something like that I can make a BUR.

I've updated the BUR because I found out that the outfit has a canon name. Google also returns more results for "Robin Dress" than "Lady Phantomhive" so I think it should be fine to rename it.

The bulk update request #23161 (forum #268205) has been approved by @nonamethanks.