Make "sleeves_past_wrists" automatically add "long sleeves" tag

BUR #8956 has been rejected.

create implication sleeves_past_wrists -> long_sleeves

Sleeves that are long enough to go past the wrist are most likely going to be long sleeves.

What about detached sleeves like: post #4995517

Previous: topic #19266

Guaro said:

What about detached sleeves like: post #4995517

Those are still long sleeves.

Nameless_Contributor said:

Previous: topic #19266

It really is annoying to tag both tbh

Unbreakable said:

Those are still long sleeves.

Yep, detatched sleeves would still be considered sleeves;; otherwise it wouldn't be considered "long sleeves" at all

vampdere said:

Yep, detatched sleeves would still be considered sleeves;; otherwise it wouldn't be considered "long sleeves" at all

This was obviously not the question. Sleeves can be short and still be part the wrist, if they're detached.
Another thing would be cases like post #2547908 were you can only assume the lenght of the sleeve.

Some argument could be made for cases of oversized clothes with short sleeves like post #1302422.

Mexiguy said:

Some argument could be made for cases of oversized clothes with short sleeves like post #1302422.

That's a good point, actually;; personally, I would just tag that as oversized clothes, although I'm not very sure about what others may think. Technically that could be considered long sleeves though, right? Since it goes past her arms? Or maybe a new tag like oversized_sleeves could be created? My main argument is that it's annoying to tag both long sleeves and sleeves past wrists

Guaro said:

This was obviously not the question. Sleeves can be short and still be part the wrist, if they're detached.
Another thing would be cases like post #2547908 were you can only assume the lenght of the sleeve.

I don't get what you mean, how would that be sleeves past wrists?

vampdere said:

I don't get what you mean, how would that be sleeves past wrists?

The photo at the very bottom.

Provence said:

The photo at the very bottom.

Ah, I see.
Wouldn't that still be long sleeves? I mean, it does go past her wrist.

vampdere said:

Ah, I see.
Wouldn't that still be long sleeves? I mean, it does go past her wrist.

I would have tagged it long_sleeves without hesitation, common sense and all that.

Unbreakable said:

Those are still long sleeves.

Not according to the long sleeves wiki as defined since 2011.

Detached sleeves may still apply if the sleeves begin at least from the middle of upper arms.

NWF_Renim said:

Not according to the long sleeves wiki as defined since 2011.

Then how should they be tagged? They are not short sleeves at all.

Sleeves_past_wrists -long_sleeves Interesting discussion because I was tagging just sleeves past wrists and just sleeves past fingers.

vampdere said:

It really is annoying to tag both tbh

It really isn't.

I say this speaking as a long-time tag gardener who frequently has to add both tags because the uploader couldn't be bothered to use either.

The bulk update request #8956 (forum #205965) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.