Donmai

imply memes to the meme tag

Posted under Tags

user 536050

BUR #7392 has been rejected.

Show

create implication special_feeling_(meme) -> meme
create implication salt_bae_(meme) -> meme
create implication space_cat_(meme) -> meme
create implication shirt_cut_meme -> meme
create implication iced_latte_with_breast_milk_(meme) -> meme
create implication my_little_pogchamp_(meme) -> meme
create implication think_mark_think!_(meme) -> meme
create implication waterskiing_(meme) -> meme
create implication pectoral_envy_(meme) -> meme
create implication retweet_(meme) -> meme
create implication distracted_boyfriend_(meme) -> meme
create implication servants_holding_aphrodite's_breasts_(meme) -> meme
create implication grand_prix_richmond_crackstyle_(meme) -> meme
create implication for_the_better_right?_(meme) -> meme
create implication broly_culo_(meme) -> meme
create implication laughing_girls_(meme) -> meme
create implication loss_(meme) -> meme
create implication as_long_as_they're_happy_(meme) -> meme
create implication apu_spills_his_tendies_(meme) -> meme
create implication chokeposting_(meme) -> meme
create implication pop_cat_(meme) -> meme
create implication trade_offer_(meme) -> meme
create implication just_do_it_(meme) -> meme
create implication pacha_meme -> meme
create implication jazz_for_your_soul_(meme) -> meme
create implication memetaa -> meme
create implication goddamn_it_kris_(meme) -> meme
create implication asirpa_clubs_the_seal_(meme) -> meme
create implication smug_trap_(meme) -> meme
create implication man_looking_at_noose_(meme) -> meme
create implication yee_(meme) -> meme
create implication hanami_trace_(meme) -> meme

I think this BUR is pretty self-explanatory: implicate all meme tags with more than 10 pictures to the actual meme tag.

Reply
Veraducks Alex MKW Unbreakable MegaFlare mortalkombachan Elfaleon
user 536050

Unbreakable said:

forum #162899 (just like topic #19555)

Ah. Well, shit. My apologies for not searching first.

But some of those threads bring up a good point; what's the point of the meme tag at all if it's so inconsistently applied? Like, I understand not bothering implicating low-usage memes, but for memes with literally hundreds of images, it seems like "half are tagged meme and half aren't" is worse from a janitorial perspective than a simple implication.

Reply
Veraducks

The two ways I could see it being a useful tag is either to implicate all memes to meme, which we refuse to do, or to write a clause and garden/enforce said clause about not tagging named memes with the generic meme tag, which would be an even bigger nightmare.

Thus, from what I can observe, we're going to leave the slightly festering sore of a tag as-is, as the only other option is nuking due to uselessness. But it's not useless. So it shall fester and hopefully stay at "slightly".

Reply
user 499293

The other option is to make it like cosplay where tagname_(meme) automatically adds meme. I don't know if evazion wants more auto-tags like that, though. It also means we'd have to rename every meme to end in _(meme), if some don't.

Implicating every new meme to crop up will be a pain to do otherwise.

Reply
1