Donmai

reflecting pool

Posted under Tags

Shinjidude

I'd argue to mass update and save "reflecting pool" for the structure named that that is specifically intended to hold reflective water in a Victorian era park, or the US capitol, or things along those lines (as in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflecting_pool ), though I don't currently see anything like that in reflecting pool currently. I'm not sure if we have any instances of that on the site or not, but I think that's what "reflecting pool" is specifically meant to mean in most instances. If it's not something we'd ever tag I guess it doesn't matter, but with an alias, it'd be difficult to tag properly.

Reply
user 418258

Shinjidude said:

I'd argue to mass update and save "reflecting pool" for the structure named that that is specifically intended to hold reflective water in a Victorian era park, or the US capitol, or things along those lines (as in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflecting_pool ), though I don't currently see anything like that in reflecting pool currently. I'm not sure if we have any instances of that on the site or not, but I think that's what "reflecting pool" is specifically meant to mean in most instances. If it's not something we'd ever tag I guess it doesn't matter, but with an alias, it'd be difficult to tag properly.

If there are many posts with this style, then we can do the same for other conflicts:
Perform a merge (alias);
Wait for established use (a couple of months?);
Separate tags and fill in correctly.
If there are few tags (reflecting pool), then the last step is performed without filling and writing a wiki.

Post № 2000619 2000618 1997762 1996306 1996293 1996285.
It was originally intended, but users did not understand the tag.

Reply
1