Donmai

[Fate] Oda Nobunaga and Cú Chulainn

Posted under Tags

I was reading through a discussion on alternate versions in the Swimsuit Servant Alts topic, and there was a brief discussion on "_(all)" tags.

Unbreakable said:

I'd say 3-4 sounds like a good limit, they should preferably also have at least a couple hundred posts on each tag for it to be worthwhile.

While looking through Fate characters that have multiple alternate forms, I was wondering about Oda Nobunaga and Cú Chulainn's alternates. Nobunaga has several versions attributed to her: Koha-Ace (1544 posts), Swimsuit Berserker (288 posts), Maou Avenger (99 posts), and Kippoushi (25 posts).

Same thing for Cu, who has at least 5 alternate versions: FSN (2819 posts), Prototype (192 posts), Caster (328 posts), Berserker (346 posts), and Prisma Illya (33 posts).

I know for certain that the high amount of posts for their original forms is due to tagging with their alternates, and I figured that Nobbu's Kippoushi self would be tagged separately from the rest of her forms (similar to how Arthur is not counted under "artoria_pendragon_(all)" and Carmilla isn't counted under "elizabeth_bathory_(fate)_(all)").

Would you say they warrant an "_(all)" tag, or should we leave it as is?

Updated

Mysterious_Uploader said:

You forgot his Fate/EXTRA version, but apparently there isn't a tag for that.

The last link is broken, it should be lancer_(prisma_illya)

With him and EXTRA Archer, I figured the lack of tag for them was due to the fact that they were mostly the same character, sort of like how Prisma Illya Shirou shares his tag with FSN Shirou but Miyu's brother doesn't.

Also edited the last link so it works properly. Thanks!

1