Donmai

Flag Vandalism

Posted under General

@indexador2 To which posts are you referring? We don't delete entire sets of images unless they all belong to a comic series that wouldn't make sense as individual pages. Flag bad images and leave good ones; never mind "consistency".

Also, keep in mind that ordinary users can flag at most one post per day, so it's unrealistic to expect whoever is flagging the images in question to take on a large number all at once.

iridescent_slime said:

@indexador2 To which posts are you referring? We don't delete entire sets of images unless they all belong to a comic series that wouldn't make sense as individual pages. Flag bad images and leave good ones; never mind "consistency".

Also, keep in mind that ordinary users can flag at most one post per day, so it's unrealistic to expect whoever is flagging the images in question to take on a large number all at once.

I can’t tell if he’s being sarcastic or serious. Either way, dealing in absolutes isn’t a good way to go about a matter like this.

I am serious, and refering to Takashia's Portland series. They're similar and flagged for the same reason, there's no pointing in flagging one and not the other. Since the flagger was accused of vandalism, I wanted to express my opinion that the behavior is the what I'd expect of someone who is serious about the art quality of the site.

iridescent_slime said:

@indexador2 To which posts are you referring? We don't delete entire sets of images unless they all belong to a comic series that wouldn't make sense as individual pages. Flag bad images and leave good ones; never mind "consistency".

Also, keep in mind that ordinary users can flag at most one post per day, so it's unrealistic to expect whoever is flagging the images in question to take on a large number all at once.

You also have to keep in mind that even if it's an user with multiple flags that they can only flag 10 posts if these images are uploaded by the same user. Which in all honesty is a very outdated "feature" now that uploader/top tagger names are essentially gone.

indexador2 said:

I am serious, and refering to Takashia's Portland series. They're similar and flagged for the same reason, there's no pointing in flagging one and not the other. Since the flagger was accused of vandalism, I wanted to express my opinion that the behavior is the what I'd expect of someone who is serious about the art quality of the site.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯ No accusation was made, simply asking if it's the same person. Or should I open an entire thread for that? Would it make you feel better?
As for Portland art, I failed to see the problem, but hey, I'm not a connoisseur of this so I'm not even gonna bother throwing my two cents in. If you guys here think it's a valid flag, then so be it.

The posts in question are marked by several approvers as "poor quality", for example one of those has 3 poor quality mark. If that's the case then a flag can hardly be invalid since they usually act independent of each other and the flagger.

1 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 66