Donmai

Deletion appeal thread

Posted under General

This topic has been locked.

I uploaded two replacement posts back when we started replacing image samples. The samples where quickly deleted and the full images went through the moderation cue, where they were reviewed by one moderator and got deleted. Now that we have the replacing system in place I would ask that the original sample posts get re-approved and replaced with their superior quality image.

post #2253826
post #2253847

ion288 said:

I uploaded two replacement posts back when we started replacing image samples. The samples where quickly deleted and the full images went through the moderation cue, where they were reviewed by one moderator and got deleted. Now that we have the replacing system in place I would ask that the original sample posts get re-approved and replaced with their superior quality image.

post #2253826
post #2253847

The 1 moderator reviewed it thing is a bug. It received proper review. If we saw it and didn't like it by then, then it's an appeal on the basis of quality, not on if it should be deleted just because the upload was active at one point.

By the way, that appeal is invalid -- we did not have a policy of not hard replacing samples by then, so by all means anyone could have replaced it. image sample has some new stuff written into it that's worth taking a look now.

Mikaeri said:

The 1 moderator reviewed it thing is a bug. It received proper review. If we saw it and didn't like it by then, then it's an appeal on the basis of quality, not on if it should be deleted just because the upload was active at one point.

By the way, that appeal is invalid -- we did not have a policy of not hard replacing samples by then, so by all means anyone could have replaced it. image sample has some new stuff written into it that's worth taking a look now.

Im mostly just sad I accidentally got two exceptional quality posts deleted. How does the appeal button work. It seems like the appeals just stick around for months without any indication if moders see or review them.